Food here is amazing ! Blake was our server and he did a phenomenal job! He was very attentive and made sure our table was squeaky clean! He also made me drink that was very delicious ! The lamb and the shrimp Alfredo was mouth watering and the apple strudels dessert was delicious! My only complaint was a they had an issue with the outside power and so the fan and the lights on one side were out however we did move seats to be closer to a fan and that definitely changed the experience. They accommodated us in every way. 10/10
My wife and I celebrated our 15 year anniversary at Martin's and we both enjoyed it. They didn't have any ginger beer or ginger ale (I asked for a Moscow Mule) so I just asked the staff to make something similar, and I wasn't dissapointed. I had the Grouper, my wife had the lobster, and we split the vegetables. The vegetables were pretty plain so I don't think I'd order those again, but everything else was good. A bit pricey here, but for special occasions, I'd recommend it.
We live in Tampa Bay and are visiting Key West. Last night (6-2-23) we ate at Martin’s. The food was absolutely divine! We ordered a bottle of Prosecco and that was delicious as well. Our waiter was excellent, wish I could remember his name..he was a tall man, very very informative and nice.
My only complaint is the bartender. We were a few minutes early for our reservation so we waited by the host stand for literally 4 minutes while our table was being prepared. I caught her looking at me and then making faces and cracking up with another employee, repeatedly. I caught her doing this, we locked eyes and she had no care that I saw this happening. It was extreme uncomfortable and she would be my only hesitation about returning. Sad, and that’s why I took points off for atmosphere.
Hands down our best dining experience in Key West. Sat at the bar for happy hour. Be sure to arrive before the 4pm opening! Waiting in line was well worth it. Everything we had was outstanding! Bartender was kind enough to make me a mocktail since I’m pregnant. Can’t wait to come back and enjoy the martinis!!
The food was absolutely amazing. Drinks were spot on.
The waiter was patient, polite and attentive.
Had the bone in rib eye. It was worth every penny! My sister in law had the bolognase sauce and pasta. It was my birthday and brought this out. It was so good.
We had two wonderful experiences at Martin's Happy Hour. Martinis and other drinks half price, but more amazing were the half price plates. The lamb chops, Waldorf salad, bratwurst particularly stood out. Must visit Happy Hour.
Great service and obvious pride in their owner and cuisine. Great choice for a business meal or a romantic dinner.
The host and staff was very accommodating. The lamb chops were amazing. Blake was an amazing server. 10/10 recommend.
A very nice restaurant with good food and service. As a vegetarian, I had a Vegetable Alfredo as my main course. The veg was perfectly cooked - still a little crunchy. The pasta was delicious too. The waiter was at times a little abrupt, which we found surprising given the service we'd experienced elsewhere on our trip.
My wife and I stopped in for dinner on a Friday night. Scallops to start, beef wellington & black grouper entrees with picked cabbage and mashed potatoes a la carte...everything was excellent! The service was wonderful too. I would definitely recommend.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Key West
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes