Pi Infinite Combinations
19 S 3rd St - Fernandina Beach
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#13 of 113 restaurants in Fernandina Beach
Updated on
€€
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
83/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🌳
Outdoor seating
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
🍺
Alcohol
🍷
Wine
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
157
Google reviews
Tremendous pizza! Very tasty. We got a 20" yes I said 20" pie. Pepperoni all over and half green olive, the green olive because my wife has questionable tastes lol. Very nice outside area to eat. Lush greenery, and a relaxing atmosphere.
Google
I think this was one of the best pizzas on the island! I'm a traditional type person that prefers to kero it simple and most of the time I order pepperoni pizza wherever I go. Pi Infinate truly makes a great pie. Wonderful ambiance in the courtyard
Google
Gave it 4 stars because I haven't tried the pizza yet....went for lunch and had a salad (which was wonderful)....but pizza was being served at the table near me and it smelled so wonderful I nearly came out of my chair! Going back tonight to try some. If it tastes as good as it looked and smelled, the fifth star is a given. Nice court yard, good wine, friendly service...no frills...just attention to good food.
Read more
Google
Was intrigued by the menu, laughed my ass off at the putzes who left bad reviews, so I'm leaving a good one. I don't generally leave reviews. I've been looking for an authentic NY style pizza and this is the closest I've ever had. FRESH ingredients with REAL flavor (who ever thought their pepperoni tastes weird have probably only had franchise pizza and don't know what real pepperoni is supposed to taste.) You know its authentic when its thin and you gotta fold it to fit it I. Your mouth. Seems pricey but the pizza is HUGE. I cannot stress this enough, the sauce has real flavor, none of this bland nonsense. Also, the pizza arrived hot and under the time they said it would take. 5 Stars!
Read more
Google
🍕🍕❤️ we brought a doggy friend to eat with us! It was sunny when we left but poured on our way here. By the time we got here it was sunny! They were really kind and wiped everything down for us so we could have dry seats! They even helped us bring everything outside. They are so nice. And 100% dog friendly. They even asked us if we needed water for our dog! We have been here before for the pizza. We always order the margherita. It’s amazing. The sauce is really flavorful and the crust is perfect. Crunchy, but not too hard. 😍😍
Read more
Google
Went there today as same review as the person who said inside is "sketchy". Nothing about this place is sketchy? I'm not sure if that's serious or not. This place is downtown and absolutely beautiful inside and out. Staff is great owner came out and boxed my pizza. Pizza was amazing. They deliver as well
Read more
Google
The best pizza in town (and this town has a lot of good pizza). Traditional margherita, classic American, and all sorts of modern pizza available by the slice or as a whole pie. Great staff & owners too, very kind and friendly.
Google
We ordered 2 large pies and really enjoyed. The pepperoni tastes more like sliced Italian sausage but I enjoyed it. Good stuff!
Google
Absolutely delicious! A little pricey but the slices/pies are huge! The marinara sauce is so tasty. Must visit if you're in the area!! It's definitely a new favorite place of mine for sure!
Google
Best pizza and salads in Fernandina. Whenever I'm in the area I have to get a whole pie to bring back to the family in Jacksonville. Would suggest to go before their stated closing time because they sometimes lock the gate early.
Google
Explore more in Fernandina Beach
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: