Great food. Wonderful service. Good portion size. Definitely will dine there again.
After some impromptu house hunting, we decided to go to Geraldi's for dinner. The antipasto salad and Pesto pizza were divine, but the personal wine tasting by Andy was the best! Delicioso
I’ve had pizza in Springfield, Joplin, and all around southwest Missouri and this is by far the best.
We spoke with the owner, what a great guy! We live in Mount Vernon and this was most definitely worth the trip to Cassville! Crispy, chewy crust! Amazing cheese! Perfect pizza!
I dined it and it was a very sweet experience! Don't expect the staff to work like a larger restaurant, there will be one or very sweet two girls who check on your table. The food there is so good! I've had people recommend the restaurant to me for a while and I am very very glad they did!
P.s. try the artichoke dip, you won't be disappointed!
The restaurant is tucked into a small space with a few other shops, almost hidden from the rest of the world. But once you discover it, it's like opening the hidden treasure chest.
I asked the server, a kind young woman named Hannah, what she would recommend. She didn't steer me wrong.
The veggie pesto pizza was cooked to perfection, and the added chicken was just right. I could tell the ingredients were fresh, and everything was made meticulously to ensure I had the best experience. Even the tea tasted just-made, a rare feat in today's world.
And Hannah made sure I had everything I needed. She was attentive and never left the dining floor without asking if I wanted something more.
Overall, a wonderful experience. I plan on coming in the next time I'm in Fayetteville.
I am local to Fayetteville and LOVE Geraldi’s. It’s an owner-operated, family-run, down-to-earth restaurant that is cozy inside and has awesome tasty food. Every time we visit, the staff is so kind and the food consistently great - whether you order pizza, pasta, calzones, salads… it’s all so good.
I also appreciate the reasonable pricing for the generous portions. You can tell the owner wants to serve great food at realistic prices with great service.
This is one of those local places you want to keep supporting and coming back to.
Was a nice experience overall. The place is a little smaller than I expected, but well maintained, and the layout was very roomy.
Got the Spicy Shrimp Alfredo and was very much in love with my food. Good spice(added spicy Italian sausage to it for more kick) and the portion size was amazing. Well worth coming here and the pricing is right for the meal you receive. 5/5
The bread alone is worth the visit. Our party enjoyed the Spicy Shrimp Alfredo but didn't care so much for the Spaghetti and Meatballs. Barely any parking
Hana was our server and she did great handling things on her own. I'm not the biggest fan of Italian, but I think anyone who is a fan of Italian this place would be amazing.
This place is a hidden treasure. Recommended by friends for their pizza, I tried the lasagna and my wife had a shrimp pasta. We also had an appetizer of spinach artichoke dip with garlic french bread. Everything was amazing. Highly recommend this place and look forward to trying their pizza next.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Fayetteville
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes