Staff was friendly and not overbearing. Clean and great seaside atmosphere. My friend had Frog legs. Said they were very good. Think the side salad could be on a larger dish rather then a very small coffee plate. My cat fish filets were ok. Thought the batter was bland. Okra and onion rings super. Could serve a bit more rings however. Highly recommend this place.
Charity McCormick Gray
+5
There aren't enough words to describe how amazing this establishment is! The service was top notch. Our server was Jen; she was extremely friendly and made sure we were taken care of the entire time. The food.. The food was phenomenal! The only word I have for it. Every single bite. We started with the gator fries, he had the catfish, I had the spicy mango shrimp pineapple bowl, and we finished with the most delicious chocolate cake I've ever had! Everything was cooked, seasoned, and presented with perfection. If you have been curious about this place and haven't tried it out yet, go try it asap! You will not be disappointed!!
We had a great time. Emily and Crystal were both very kind. We enjoyed our food and everyone was so nice! Happy 22nd birthday Emily! We hope you have an amazing weekend! Thank you so much for great service and food! We look forward to coming back in a couple weeks when we come back through!
We had Courtney as our server. She always takes care of us and makes sure we have everything we need to have the most amazing experience. I absolutely love the friend green tomatoes, boils, and the gator fries are to die for! Always satisfied when I eat here. This place is a go to for me and my fiancé and recommend it to those looking for some good seafood and fried green tomatoes!!!
Gator Po' Boy and spicy fish tacos were amazing. Fries had the perfect amount of seasoning.
Courtney was very helpful and friendly. Will certainly ask for her next time we stop in.
Danuielle Shafer Hardin
+5
I came in with my daughter for a late lunch and ordered the Fish and Shrimp Hawaiian plate. It was delicious. Courtney was our server and we was so friendly and accommodating. I would definitely recommend this venue and server. Mahalo, Courtney!!
Hosted by Crystle & Emily; Wonderful. I've found another gem in Evansville. Normally, I would drink 5 glasses of water to offset the serving size, but not today. Ashamed, as a "professional eater "I didnt finish my meal. The shrimp & grits wore me out & I was full before my 2nd 16oz glass of water. For you bonecrushers, the catfish was well seasoned & fried hard just the way it supposed to be. 25$ later & I'm full. DavidLeeRoth's (VanHalen) "I ain't got nobody" as I try to think on who to tell (chuckles) If it's the Lord's will , I will return several times just to make sure that I didnt like it the first time (hahaha).
Husband asked where I wanted to go for Valentines. I picked Catfish Willy's. Then, I found out they were closed on Sundays. We delayed our Valentines until I was off on a Monday night. We finally had our night out and were not disappointed! We could have made a meal out of the Bubbly Hot Crab and Seafood dip. It was oh so cheesy, creamy, flavorful, you could see the shrimp and taste the crab. The toast was crispy and crunchy and made this appy perfect. We did order meals, I got theSeafood Platter, had fried catfish, Orka and clams, oysters. It was all fried perfect. And ALOT of food. We had a wonderful time. The decor was in transition. I can't wait to return and see the new updates. The waitress was very attentive and kept our drinks full. She was very knowledgeable about the menu and what her favorites were. It is always nice to know the wait staff eat where they work. If you have not tried Catfish Willy's, you should!
Crystal was our waitress!! She was AWESOME!! She recommended the King Crab and it didn’t disappoint!! We have been before and we will keep coming back! Great service! 10 out of 10 experience!! Even have leftovers!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Evansville
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes