Edgartown Seafood

Bob Fiorito

The new owners are great! Got some fresh sword and the cut it to order. Stuffed clams and stuffed scallops were delicious with plenty of meat

Evan Hamilton

Not at all what I expected but it turned into a blessing in disguise. Edgartown Seafood turned out to be a fish market but still offered some of the FRESHEST soup and lobster rolls that I have ever tasted in my entire life. It was sad to see that they weren't more populated, because people who are not coming here are really missing out. While this place does not at all have any tables to sit at, there was a park just a few hundred yards away (walkable distance) where we sat and ate on the benches. While we are tourists, this was a great experience, and next time we come to Martha's Vineyard this will definitely be some place that we will come back too.

Todd Anderman

Always delicious with laid back, friendly service. Lobsters cooked to order :-)