This is a gourmet restaurant at reasonable cost. I travel a lot and the food here is spectacular and some of the best I have ever had! They have something for everyone, including pizza for kids and homemade pasta. A must go to!
One of my favorite restaurants on island, the food is creative and each bite blows your mind, in the best way possible. The last meal I had there was a favorite of all times, every course so exciting and gorgeous and delicious! Perfect for date night or a group of friends wanting to taste a few different things, lots of good sharable items!
![5]( "Recensione")
Very nice classy place, from the greeters to the servers everything was great. We started with a garden salad that was good. The server also brought out some warm bread with what I think was a chimichurri sauce. Tasted very good. We ordered the chicken parm, the broccoli rabe and sausage cavatelli, and also the spaghetti and meatballs. The parm was a nice thick piece of breast and tasted awesome. The broccoli rabe and sausage was good but in my opinion not as good as the parm. Spaghetti and meatballs was excellent too. The kids even ate everything! I also ordered the Isola cooler drink 2x. I liked it alot. Last but not least was the dessert... We decided on the dough nuts and ice cream, and also the orange olive oil cake. While they were both good the doughnuts were probably 10x better. They were so good, my little boy said they taste just like fried dough 🤤! I will only order those next time. Overall the service was great. They were all very attentive and didn't pester you every few mins. Even the people who weren't our "server" were helpful if we needed something. I would for sure come back and recommend.
Brian “Bmanpitt” Pitcher
+5
Very authentic and brillant family staff. Always looking for new dishes and superb thin crust pizza takeout..
Everything was perfect! The food was delicious with professional friendly service. One of our meals was the special, sea scallops. SO good!! We visit MV in the summer and this is our second time here. We will be back next year! Compliments to Peter and the staff!
We were in the mood for pizza and cozy atmosphere and this fit the bill perfectly. We didn't have a reservation so we sat at the bar which worked out great. Dave was a great bartender and we had a grilled romaine salad and a margarita pizza. Both were great. Hearing conversations around us this is definitely a place the locals go which is a good sign. We will definitely return.
I had the half chicken and my friend had pasta with vodka sauce. The flavors were so good in both dishes, and the portions are perfect! Definitely enough to feel stuffed at the end (And I took some home). Highly recommend and I'll be coming back to try more soon.
By far, the Best meal and incredible service on the Vineyard,
We’ve been here at least 6 times over the past 1 1/2 years and the variety of home made local dishes are second to none.
The owner and his three children are here on a nightly basis and can be found mingling with their guests and always make sure that their guests are treated with care and the best service on the Vineyard!
The only thing I don't like about Isola is that it is not easy to find. Everything else is phenomenal.
There are two different parts to this place: the restaurant and the pizzeria.
The restaurant food is delicious and interesting, if a bit pricy, with good vegetarian options. The service is quite fast and the staff are very friendly.
The pizza and salads at the pizzeria are both excellent and come quickly.
There is outdoor seating for both parts and it is quite nice.
Tucked away, quiet restaurant that serves good food. The grilled romaine salad was delicious. The pasta is fresh (!) and perfectly cooked al dente. The wait staff very pleasant and eager to please. A nice, relaxed place for an enjoyable dinner.
Great homemade pasta. The appetizers are large and perfect for sharing. The pizza is just okay - not spectacular. Overall it's a great place for an Italian dinner on the vineyard.
When your craving some good Italian food don't go anywhere else but Isola. The red sauce is so fresh and homemade not from a can the meatballs were delicious. Broccoli rabe with sausage and garlic was very good. I usually don't find the authenticity I can't speak highly enough about it. Usually I have to make it at home to get what I'm craving. The service was very good. I could give them 10 stars!! I'm Italian so bravo guys👏
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Edgartown
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes