It was delicious pizza for our party. I liked the pizza with pineapple, I'm not sure about the name because I didn't place the order, but it looks a lot like Hawaiian Pizza (pizza sauce, cheese, cooked ham, and pineapple).
All pizzas were delivered on time in good condition and we ate everything quickly.
I used to go to Luigi's years ago. I came back to LI for a wedding and took my grown children to a "real" pizza parlor, cuz VA does not know what real pizza is. They were blown away and I wanted to move back to LI the next day. I gotta come back up when I have time to kill and eat some of your pizza again.
The cauliflower pizza is very good (GF). The kids like their regular pizza too. The service is good, easy and quick. The atmosphere leaves a lot to be desired. Aim for take out.
Vegan pizza!! Run, do not walk, for their amazing food. I love their regular pizza but to have a good vegan pizza for my dairy free friends puts them over the top.
I love this place. I have been going here for years. My favorite... their specialty slices!! All yum!! I have had luncheons here for work related parties, and they do a great job. Luigi's has a pizza area & and the dining area is a little small but still worth going. You won't be disappointed.
Not the least expensive place but considering the area and clientele it's fine. They do have fine in with good service but a significant part of the good is take out and it's busy! Meatball parmigiana heroes and past rústica are my faves?
Wow. Very impressed with the quality. We loved the pizza. It is thin, nice texture and the crust is great.
It's been two years since I've had Luigi's - in that time I've had many new pizza experiences, so I was genuinely unsure whether it would still hold up my provocative opinion that it's the 'best pizza in the world™'
I ate four slices and I can still conclusively say it's the best in the world and I'll die on that hill. If you find yourself in Setauket Long Island, pick up a pizza there to have your world view permanently altered
The gluten-free penne is always good, and the 'bodybuilder with grilled chicken' is loaded with healthy vegetables and really tasty. 😋
I ordered a medium vegan pie on their site. I didn’t realize I was so far from them but someone called and said they would still deliver which I really appreciated since my daughter really wanted pizza. She loved the pizza! Great customer service 💕
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in East Setauket
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes