Wise & Plenty

Wise & Plenty, East Quogue 674 Montauk Hwy, East Quogue NY 11942, United States - East Quogue

American
• Healthy
• Café

90/100
Give a rating

What's your favorite Wise & Plenty's dish?

Ratings and reviews

90
/100
Based on 259 ratings and reviews
Updated

Ratings of Wise & Plenty

Google
Google
Last update on 24/12/2023
4,5
199 Reviews

Reviews

5
Shamira Shariffudin
+5
We catered from Cucina for an event and all of our guests loved the food. Chef Gaitano and his staff opened the kitchen early on a Saturday to have our order ready for lunch. He even threw in a few extras and called me the next day to make sure everything went well - we couldn't thank them enough!
5
Steven Tringali
+5
Excellent italian family style food. The staff are all very nice and the service just awesome. Gaitano runs the place and treats you like family. The fettucini alfredo is just awesome as well as the stuffed rigatoni!!! I will be a regular!!!
5
Jarred Reiling
+5
This place has been renamed Del Sol under new management, and it is delicious! We visited from out of town: had the Stromboli, Calzone, Margherita Pizza, and Shrimp con Tostones. Service was great (thanks, Steve). Definitely recommend!
5
Andrea
+5
First time customer and was greeted with a warm welcome by a friendly man who seemed to maybe be the owner. He told us that you can except real homemade Italian & he was right. I even got a meatball sample and it was the best I’ve ever had. My boyfriend got scampi and said it was the best shrimp he’s ever had. This place is a hidden gem!
5
Ilana Vachani
+5
We catered from the restaurant (they recently changed ownership) for a group of ~20. The food was ready on time, it was hot, and delicious! Some of the highlights were the stuffed mushrooms, chicken franchese, mozzarella carozza, and baked ziti. Highly recommend if you need wonderful Italian food for a larger group!
5
m r
+5
Great food, Chef Gaetano is very welcoming. Everything is homemade, family style. We tried several different sauces, all were delicious in their own way. We had ordered two specials for the night- chicken scarpiello- very good. My favorite was the nonas gravy with sausage and meatballs and fresh pasta. Regular slice and grandma, fresh garlic knots- all very tasty. Best around for Italian IMO.
5
Mike D
+5
Delicious everything is amazing huge portions fresh great food nice and polite people great environment all around hands down one of the best places out east for Italian food if u haven't been you have to go there !!!
5
Steven LaBiner
+5
Absolutely the Best Pasta since I've been on the East-End! The House Ministrone was hearty and delicious!
5
Jan Willem den Daas
+5
Wow! The portions here are amazing! We went with our whole family (about 15 people) and we just ordered some of the pastas, salads and fish. It was more than enough, and everyone could have a little bit of everything, which I always love to do! We have also ordered pizza from here a couple of times, and the pizza is also outstanding! Hope we go here again next year! Oh and the owner has a bunch of classic cars out front for any enthusiasts :)
4
Thorin Teak
+4
An awesome meal if with a large group. Family style sit down with a pleasant atmosphere. Great pizzas and heroes. Friendly staff. A little hard to find , set way back off the road , but worth while trying to find.

Description

Read the reviews on

Google
Google

Info

Compare the best restaurants near Wise & Plenty

bianca Sluurpy rate Google rate Facebook rate
TA

Wise & Plenty

90 4.5

Our aggregate rating, “Sluurpometro”, is 90 based on 259 parameters and reviews

If you need to contact by phone, call the number +1 631-996-4550

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT
1