Paula's Cafe

Bit of a let down since I read so many great reviews. We decided to try authentic Neapolitan pizza after watching "The Pizza Show" series on TV and seeing what is required to be certified. Our 2 pizzas unfortunately didn't look as good as the others I've seen in reviews or Google images for Pizzaplex. Burnt crust beyond normal Neapolitan stole some enjoyment. Pizza flavor was good, the crust that wasn't over cooked was tasty. Cheese wasn't melted very well making it difficult to get the full experience. The tiramisu, although flavorful, was not as pictured either. Unfortunately it was eaten by the person that ordered it before I could get a picture. Friendly staff, nice interior, fair pricing. Glad we tried it, likely won't make the 20 minute drive for another. My review is overall based on 3 people's opinion and 2 pizzas and a dessert. In all fairness, every place should get 2 tries to determine overall quality. I would NOT tell anyone else not to give it a try first. They get an extra star for being good stewards in the neighborhood. It's nice to see the area making a rebound.

Date night at PizzaPlex - both pizzas were delicious. Tried the amaro flight, and the server was very knowledgeable about each offering. Great cocktail selection too - we’ll be back!

Excellent pizza, crust is chewy with a slight crisp, sauce is delicious made with San Marzano tomatoes, and toppings were high quality. Fun atmosphere, there was karaoke going on when I was there. This is one of the best pizzas I've had in the area!

Best pizza in the h00d. Been grabbing pizza from here since they opened. I've been tearing the diavola up while my wife has been going through the one covered in porcini mushrooms. Seems like they cycle through employees rather often so don't let one lackluster food experience turn you against the place , once they hit a stride, they absolutely kill it.