Bennolli's

Terrible. Were told our cooked pizza would be ready in 20 minutes. We arrived a couple minutes early so waited in the car out front. During that time, we watched one of the two employees repeatedly blowing his nose and handling his snotty tissue. When another customer walked in, he went right back to work without washing. The other employee didn't even seem to notice and there didn't appear to be a manager on site. At that point, we went in to ensure he would not handle our pizza and had to request multiple times just to get him to go wash his hands. He didn't seem to act like he thought it was a big deal. Although it had been 20 minutes, they hadn't even started our pizza yet. We ended up leaving with a take and bake, made by the other employee whom we hope had clean hands. It was upsetting because we had frozen pizza at home already but did not want to wait 20 minutes to cook at home. Since we ended up with an uncooked pizza anyway, I would have rather just thrown in one of our frozen pizzas. Everything was terrible.

I have been to Bennolli's Pizza quite a few times and have loved it! The service was quicker than I thought it would be! The only thing I noticed that I don't like there is that there is one young man (blonde, tall, and maybe a manager) that is always rude to his fellow employees. Most of his rude actions are towards a young lady (brown hair with highlights, and short) that seems to be such a sweetheart! She seems to do her job with such perfection. She brought out my order for me one night with a big smile and a few kind words. Its these type of employees that bring me back to restaurants like this! I hope the owner changes the way some employees act to others that do they're job with such energy and joy. I will be back to enjoy more pizza and bread sticks and I do recommend coming here for great food when your in town!

Our family has enjoyed the pizza several times from Bennollis. While the pizza was fantastic the first couple times, it seems to have lost its appeal over time. More disturbing however is how the owner treats his employees. Sure it might be a family owned place, but I won't support any establishment where the owner treats their employees in his manner. He is short, rude and condescending toward them. It has been noted on more than one occasion. The teenagers who work there are more pleasant and friendly to deal with. Been there about 8 times, won't be back after the last episode. PS - my wife witnessed this as well on a separate occasion.

I'm from Chicago & while I'd still rather have pizza in my home town, this is the best Wisconsin pizza. The options are excellent, the crust is good, the sauces and toppings are fresh & flavorful. I've been in the restaurant for pizza pick up many times, & I've never noticed the owner berate anyone. He's always been professional & cordial to me.

Awful pizza. I am surprised this place has been open so long in a town that can be ruthless to restaurants. The crust is tasteless with a chewy texture and cardboard flavor that drowns out any other flavors from the toppings. The sausage is spongy pre formed squares that taste worse than frozen pizza sausages. Tried them twice and no luck. Would not recommend or ever try again.

Had a gift card to Bennolis so I decided to order a pizza. We told them we would pick up at 7pm ( one hour after we ordered)because that’s when we would end up being in the area. Once I picked it up I went straight home , 15minutes away and the pizza was COLD. I was disappointed. The part that really upset me about this VISIT was using my gift card. Turns out it LOSES VALUE after a year!! It was a $25 giftcard and there was only $7 on it. I got it 1.5 years ago. Apparently there’s writing on the gift card that explains this. It’s unbelievable & there’s no reason to do this to customers money.

What a waste of money, spent 20 bucks on a take and bake pizza and could have gotten better coming from papa johns or some other chain. Buyers remorse was heavy with this one. I'm rarely such a harsh critic, as I work in the industry, but this pizza was bad and expensive so I felt obligated to review. Maybe I goofed up by baking it myself but I know that the baking couldn't have made the sausage taste so fennel-forward.