Great pizza. True authentic New York style I wish we had a place like this back in Texas
2 Words. Buffalo Knots! It's a wonder why these have never been done by anyone else. The Pizza is good but the Buffalo Knots are what keep me coming back.
DELICIOUS!!!!. Soooo many varieties of pizza!!!
love the shut up & try it!!! its a must have, along with my other favorites; thai calamari & buffalo garlic knots!!! wont find better anywhere!!!!
I have 3 words. OH MY GOD!!! My husband & I are from the Florida area and found this place through Google last year and WOW!! The food is outstanding I mean truly truly amazing. The prices are great for the quality of food you get, the staff is just super, the interior is perfect, and the food was beyond perfect. You so have to try this.
My new pizza place!!. This week was terrible hurricane Sandy. I live in Deer Park and still have no power and I was so excited to hear that there was a pizzeria open during the outages. I sent my husband there and he came home with a pasta and some pizza and it was AMAZING. We've been there every night since. My life savor during the storm!! This beats the pizzeria I have been going to for years by far.
The best of everything!!!. I have 3 words. OH MY GOD!!! My husband & I are from the Florida area and found this place through Google. and WOW!! The food is outstanding I mean truly truly amazing. The prices are great for the quality of food you get, the staff is just super, the interior is perfect, and the food was beyond excellent. I would move here just to have the honor of eating Richie's cooking every night. Especially his signature Rigatoni dish. Now if I can only talk my husband into it.
Good Pizza!. Impressed by the varieties of pizza especially on a friday afternoon. My favorite is the Shut up and Try It pizza! The buffalo garlic knots are outstanding and the place is clean.
Deer Park Pizza. Deer Park Best's Pizza - Richie's Pizza, Free Delivery. What can I Say? So awesome.
AWESOME. Their pizza is fantastic, you must try the Shut Up and Try it PIE!!!
Liked it !!. One of the best chicken salads I ever had !! Great Service and prices
Super friendly staff that moves very quickly. The pizza is very good. We always call up and order a Sicilian with crumbled sausage and hot honey and everyone that tries it raves about how good it is.
Edit: Updating my review and adding back a star. I love the garlic knots here and no where else, was in the mood for them so ordered a pizza for the family as well and it was MUCH better than the past couple times we ordered.
Original review: was our go-to pizza place for years, but the last two times or so have us reconsidering. Everyone has off days so one meh pizza was not a deal breaker, but tastes like they changed their dough and the last time we ordered the pizza it was not very good, no one went back for a second slice. I hope they didn't change the dough but if so please change it back! We've been hesitant to order here again since the quality seems to have been going down.
I used to work on Pilgrim grounds and would visit this pizza place a lot. Now I dont work in the area anymore but when I am near this place it is always my go to place. I am from Brooklyn originally and this place reminds me of my youth. The selection of the pizzas is decent and the taste is GREAT! Good job guys. I definitely recommend this pizza place.
Live in the south you never forget New York Pizza 🍕 I fell in love allover again. The restaurant was very clean 👌 the food was delicious 😋 I will return to dine in my next trip to Long Island New York.
Great tasting pizza. Loved it. Got the Chicken Parm Vodka slice
Walked in after getting off work and was surprised by the atmosphere and the appearance of the store, it felt rather home like. I walked in got greeted and happily took my order, the guy who took my order spoke in Spanish, and there was another person who packed my food, I asked him how he was and we had some pleasant small talk. The people and vibes of this place sure are a plus. But the pizza is definitely quality, decided to go for a regular because a pizza places best determining factor is in fact, is if they can make a good foundation for their other slices. I am happy to say the regular slices are great. I look forward to coming back to this location and trying out their other slices
Chicken parm hero was good
Tortolini and shut up and try it are my regular choices
Tried the linguini carbonara, but was bland. Seemed like just alfredo even though the ton of peas and meat in there.
Still some of the best pizza I've had, always make it a point to stop in when I'm in the neighborhood, if you've never been there or had their garlic knots, they are a MUST !
The food is a little pricey, but the food and their portions are worth the price.
Good pizza and salads. I would have given 5 Stars but when i went there the other day, I left with both arms full. There was a teenage employee by the door cleaning the glass. He didn't attempt to open the door for me being that my arms were full. It's definitely not his responsibility, but would have been a kind respectable gesture.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Deer Park
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes