Pizza Cellar

After a long day of hiking at Indiana Dunes National Park, I decided I wanted pizza, particularly Chicago style deep dish pizza. Since Chicago was an additional 45 minutes away from my hotel, I decided to find something local. Am I glad I listened to the reviews and ordered a deep dish pizza from here! The pizza was absolutely delicious. Ordered a medium deep dish pizza with mushrooms, spinach and garlic. Would definitely recommend ordering pizza from here. Stay away from the generic chain shops and support the local businesses!

Expensive!! Large Cheese, Medium with 3 toppings, Salad(weird sweet tomato salad) and a 2-liter for just under $75. It was rather flavorless pizza. We received a free Small Deep dish cheese for spending so much which was also very sweet, but good. Staff was extremely friendly. Definitely NOT the best pizza in Crown Point.

Tried Pizza Cellar on a friend’s recommendation. Absolutely delicious chow. The crust is a pleasing amalgam of buttery crumb and crispy edge. The sauce is complex and nicely balances sweetness, acid, and herbaceousness. The homemade sausage is a medley of quality pork and spices that makes the sausage at competing pizza joints seem like swill. The fresh ingredients are superb, as is the caramelization the cooks put on the cheese. Yet somehow, this vastly superior pizza is just a few dollars more than the “discount” pizza restaurants. What’s more, Pizza Cellar’s Italian beef and Italian sausage sandwiches are the very best in town. Just order extra jus on account of they’re big. Whatever you order, you will NOT be disappointed!