Frosted
133 Main St, 13045-2925 - Cortland
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#13 of 70 restaurants in Cortland
Updated on
€€€
American
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
71/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🥡
Takeout
🚚
Delivery
♿
Wheelchair accessible
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
102
Google reviews
This is a great local Bakery. There's always a nice selection of cut,-out cookies.
Google
Margaret I will always love you! You were my best friend for so many years! Miss the old days!
Google
This place is terrific! Great variety and super service!
Google
ordered a carrot cake for a SUNY Cortland family weekend birthday. we were coming in from out of town, and hoped for the best as we were ordering a bit blind. they were not only super kind and accommodating, but the cake was exceptionally good. the frosting was super good, and the cake moist and not overly sweet. they nailed it. we will certainly go there again!
Read more
Google
They even have ruggelah! They put my expensive home town bakery to shame. We got one of many things and each was great.
Google
Coming from a Long Islander who has been eating bagel egg sandwiches for almost 2 decades, I've never had a sandwich as good as the one I had from here! The bagel, the egg, the cheese, was just perfect - I'm sad I didn't discover this place earlier!
Google
Great bakery!! My friend lives down near the city and wanted to get her grandmother, who lives local, a birthday cake. I recommend them after a coworker brought me their delicious cupcakes - Frosted did a fantastic job! I've since bought so many baked goods from them 😊 Highly recommend!
Google
Huge desserts for a great price. These cookies and cupcakes are the best in Cortland.
The s’mores is my favorite.
Google
Great gal that runs this place. I've ordered many birthday cakes through Frosted & other party treats. She is so kind and the products are delish. Try the super sugar cookie if you ever need a sugar boost. Its delish.
She did it again!! She made a beautiful cake and the gentleman who waited on me carried the cake to my truck after giving me a free cup of fresh coffee. These are our neighbors in the business of being personable and keeping their customers happy and well cared for! The service is always spot on at Frosted not too mention her line of cookies, breakfast choices and goodies.
Read more
Google
We love this place! I take my son here usually once a week for breakfast before school. He loves the bacon, egg, and cheese on a bagel. The cookies are always good, and the cupcakes are so very pretty (they taste good too, but crazy super sweet. Usually 2 bites and your good.), and the perfect size to share.
Read more
Google
Explore more in Cortland
Help improve this page: