Andrea's 25

6300 Jericho Tpke, 11725-2831 - Commack
Recommended by Sluurpy: 2025 2024 2021
🏆 #4 of 96 restaurants in Commack
Updated on
€ Italian
★★★★★ ★★★★★
4.0/5
2504 recommendations

Sluurpy Quality Index

PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
63/100
Data Completeness
72/100

Verified Dish

Add Missing Dish

4.0/5
Sluurpometro: 81/100
Sluurpy Score
2,504 total reviews
TA Trip
4.0/5
115 reviews
OT Opentable
4.0/5
941 reviews
G Google
4.5/5
234 reviews
F Foursquare
3.5/5
32 reviews
F Facebook
4.0/5
45 reviews
FM Find me gluten free
3.5/5
3 reviews
S Sirved
4.4/5
1,003 reviews
R Restaurantji
4.4/5
131 reviews

Rating distribution

5★
51
4★
46
3★
14
2★
3
1★
1
🚚 Delivery 🥡 Takeout 🍽️ Dine-in 🍺 Alcohol 🍹 Cocktails 🍷 Wine 📅 Reservations ♿ Wheelchair accessible

💬 What people say

Appetizer 10 Veal 9 Food and service 8 Price 7 Bartender 6 Chop 6 Shrimp 6 Calamari 4

Contact Information

📞 Phone: +1 631-486-7400
🌐 Website: http://www.andreas25.com
📍 Address: 6300 Jericho Tpke, Commack

🕐 Opening Hours

Open now Closes at 10:00 PM
Monday1 05:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Tuesday2 05:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday3 05:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Thursday4 05:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Friday5 05:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Saturday6 05:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Sunday7 05:00 PM - 10:00 PM

Google Reviews

4.5/5
★★★★★
234 Google reviews
M

Mary McCue

★★★★★ 5/5
Can't say enough amazing things about this place my friend Rob and I found tonight right around the corner. They were so friendly, food was great and they were incredibly kind to Abbie my service dog! The owner Peter went extremely out of his way to make sure we had a lovely experience.... thank you to all for making us feel at home! 🥰 The Casino Clams are out of this world!
Read more
Google
P

Pat B

★★★★☆ 4/5
First time here. Very happy with the muscles and calamari. Can’t wait to go back. Swordfish was ok.
Google
P

Priyanka Reddy

★★★★★ 5/5
I am a first-timer at Andrea's 25 although it's been on my bucket list for a hot second. The rave reviews made me bookmark it, and last week, my husband finally made a reservation for us for our 1st wedding anniversary. When we walked in on time at Andreas 25, there was no host/hostess for 5-10 at the front of the restaurant. We literally had to track someone down, and were seated 15 minutes late which was a bit frustrating. I would have docked a star, but the rest of our visit was flawless so I'll overlook it, and chalk it up to a busy night. We started the night with our wonderful server Peter. He recommended the Risotto Balls and Juniors Steak Crostini for appetizers out of the ones we were eyeing, and they definitely did not disappoint. Definitely excited to come back and try more of the appetizers (it was hard to pick, honestly!) I would out of the two, the steak crostini was flavorful, and was a generous amount of steak, mozzarella and other ingredients. For the main dishes we shared the Lamb chops with roasted potatoes and the Hawaiian sweet potato ravioli dish. Both were fantastic, although I do think the potatoes were mildly overdone. The ravioli was INCREDIBLE and definitely a spicy, flavorful dish, it was easily the most unique dish we had all night and I've never had anything like it! The flavors really complemented each other! The lamb was also done perfectly medium and paired really well with the cabernet sauce, and the meat was was done to PERFECTION! We also ordered a half-bottle of their Moscato D'Asti (pictured). And it was perfection! Overall, the meal was full of fresh ingredients and flavor, you can tell the chef took pride in the preciseness of the taste and ingredients he used. Our sever Peter was also gracious, gave great recommendations and was attentive the entire meal without being overbearing! We also got the Oreo Zeppolis which were good but not the best I've had. I would definitely come back for the food! I was disappointed that our anniversary was not acknowledged, as other restaurants have at least wished us, but I would say despite that that, it was 4.5 stars overall and is definitely on the pricer side for a meal, but the ingredients and service during the meal with fantastic. I would say I wish their host/hostess was at the front and that we didn't have to wait that long, but hope they fix that for future visits. The pros most definitely outweigh the couple of small things that could have just been different.
Read more
Google
M

Michael Buffalino

★★★★★ 5/5
This is a nice spot for a date night. Good ambiance and lighting, really attentive staff. The food is very good with careful attention given to each item on the plate. The shrimp oreganata was good, shrimp was cooked perfectly. The black spaghetti was very light and very tasty. The ossobucco was super tender and the risotto complimented perfectly. The Napoleon was incredible. We look forward to returning soon!
Read more
Google
A

Amy Steff

★★★★★ 5/5
First time there but definitely not the last. The ambiance was nice. The menu had a nice selection from apps to entrees. The food was absolutely amazing, where I finished Evey last bite. I rarely do, but their chicken was cooked perfect! Service was outstanding our waiter knew exactly what was on the menu and was able to answer any questions we had about the food and even warned us about certain dishes being a little spicy without us asking and that for me was a plus because I do not like spicy. Highly recommend this place!
Read more
Google
J

Joe Pascucci

★★★★☆ 4/5
We were two couples out for dinner at Andrea‘s 25. For starters we had sweet chili calamari, delicious. My entrée was a seafood risotto Luciano which was outstanding. And my wife had the Hawaiian sweet potato ravioli which was very good. They also have great specials. I’m The service was a notch or two above excellent and we all had a very good time. I would highly recommend this restaurant.
Read more
Google
L

Leona Velez

★★★★★ 5/5
It's in a strip mall, but once you're inside you completely forget that. The ambiance is nice, service was excellent and food was even better.
Google
E

Eric San José

★★★★☆ 4/5
More than just your average Italian restaurants. Clean facilities with a wheelchair accessible entrance. Public Restrooms. Service was outstanding, very accommodating! A little on the expensive side so bring your credit card, but worth the price. This place is more of a special occasion restaurant, like for a birthday or anniversary. The sweet chilli Calamari appetizer was worth coming back for. Veal chop was awesome (Picture posted). The desserts were good but not their strong point. Banana bread was good. Drinks specials on Thursday nights. If I could, I would give 4 1/2 Stars. We will definitely be going back.
Read more
Google
P

Phyllis kinzelberg

★★★★☆ 4/5
Food is very good, service is excellent, drinks are GREAT and the ambiance is nice. No complaints here. They even took a steak dish back because someone wasn't happy with it without blinking an eye. Their pasta, shrimp, and chicken dishes are delicious. They could not have been nicer. They even gave dessert and coffee to my in laws for their 65th anniversary.
Read more
Google
P

Phil Holm

★★★★★ 5/5
If there was anything better than the food, it was the service! Excellent all around. Amazing spot, glad we found it.
Google
Help improve this page:
← Back to all restaurants in Commack

🍽️ Suggest a dish

⚠️ Report error

🚫 Report closed

Do you confirm that Andrea's 25 has permanently closed?