Ye Olde Fish House

What a great find! It's a tiny place, with a limited menu, but what they have is done really well! I got the fish sandwich, and they really loaded it up! The side of mac n cheese was pretty good, too. Better than what you get at most places. And it's all super-fast, too. Got a small window of time for lunch? This is a perfect spot. The folks working there are super friendly, and you can tell that they really appreciate their customers. All that, and a drink for a $10 bill. You just can't beat it! I'm looking forward to going back and giving the tenderloin a try!

People always complain about local places with good food and service disappearing, well make sure that doesn't happen and support Ye Olde Fish House. Our first visit was great, super friendly, hot crispy fish sandwiches, the best fried taters we've had since Grandma got out the cast iron and a gooey slice of pecan pie. We could've easily spent more at a fast food place and not have had half as good a time.

When was the last time you were out to eat and a manager stopped at every table to see if everyone was satisfied. It happened at Ye Olde Fish House this week, and it was the kind of service that calls you to return. My wife and I had our first lunch at Ye Olde Fish House and it was an enjoyable experience. From the moment we walked in the door we could tell they were interested serving us with a smile, even though there were many customers in this small building. As the picture shows, the fish sandwhich is stacked high with fish which provides more fish in each bite, unlike most fastfood restaurants. Others have noted that they do not use much salt, for which I am grateful. I fully enjoyed my lunch, and I was not thirsty the rest of the day as I am with other "fried" lunches. Adding ketchup and spicy mustard gave the sandwhich a well rounded flavor. We did not try the desserts, but did enjoy the free refill on the drink that came with my meal. If you enjoy a good fish sandwhich and apprreciation when you visit a local business then Try Ye Olde Fish House. We will be back.

Always amazing food and friendly service. Definitely the best fried fish around. They have great sides too! Being someone who regularly gets discriminated against for being heavily tattooed (I'm a tattoo artist) and wild hair, it's definitely refreshing and a breath of comfort walking in here and them treating everyone with patience and smiles. You guys are awesome. Thank you for being pleasant humans 🥰 My ONLY complaint is that I cannot take my paraplegic sibling with me because this building is not wheelchair accessible.

This is a picture of half of the platter special. You get 3-4 pieces of fish, a side & a drink. It’s not a bad deal for $10 and the man that was working the counter was very friendly. I only gave it 3 stars because the fish was not hot, not even warm, more like room temperature. It lacked in seasoning. I got the potatoes and they were ok but also lacked in seasoning. The sweet tea was perfect, tasted fresh brewed with just the right amount of sweet. I might give it one more try and have the tenderloin next time, but only because of the other good reviews and the super friendly staff.

Just great food, friendly atmosphere and reasonable prices. I usually don’t review things but this place was such a great find. Can’t believe I’ve lived in Columbus for 2 years and am just now discovering it. The fish sandwich was absolutely incredible! Will be coming here a lot from now on for my lunch breaks.