Adam
Oh my goodness!!
Handel's was such a treat to stumble upon while in town for a visit.
Tried a sunday and a 4 way sampler and there wasn't one I didn't love. You can tell this ice cream is homemade and isn't just thrown together. It's been around for decades and you can tell in the quality and taste!
Houston Watson
Ordered a smores dish and it was good, although a bit on the soft and runny side like another comment noted, though it tasted good and had actual mini marshmallows. The ice cream is definitely made fresh each day as they say. For the price, hard to beat. Fast service too. Overall recommend!
A Mac
Best Ice cream in Columbus! Scoop sizes are much better than some of the other local small business ice cream shops. They also allow you to taste flavors if you need to.
You should try the chocolate cake batter and peanut butter parfait. 🤤
Stephanie Sjaardema
Delicious ice cream, so many flavors! We got the 4 scoop sampler and it was so much ice cream for the price!
The only disappointment was multiple hairs stuck in the graham cracker flavor ice cream. Please ensure quality and sanitary control of all flavors! We loved it up til this point but this made us lose our appetite and not finish the ice cream.
Ian Anthony Jurado
Picturesque icecream parlor near Columbus. Really good icecream! Creamy and not too sweet.
We tried the 4-flavor sampler and asked to put all the bestselling ones. We loved each of them - forgive me if I didn't get the name right - graham variant, a cookies and cream variant, a strawberry with cheese variant and a chocolate with peanut butter variant.
Must try and will definitely come back!
Ashley Johnson
Handel's is by far our family's favorite ice cream. We get it much more often than we should because it is so delicious. I highly recommend the Graham Central Station flavor. They have such a wide variety of flavors that there is guaranteed to be something for everyone!
Cannon
LOVE LOVE LOVE the coconut cream pie ice cream!! There are pieces of crust in the ice cream and it is flakey and delicious. I do have a suggestion, I wish that you could order all the flavors the store has on door dash. They only have a few selected flavors and I'm always craving the Coconut Cream Pie and it's never on the list but I can drive there and they have it. I guess it saves me calories lol.
Ethan Dewhurst
Incredible ice cream! Cannot believe how many flavors they have and I have yet to have one that I haven’t loved. Delicious ice cream. Great sizes and prices. Just look at the line, this is in November… Just speaks to how great their ice cream and service is! New favorite ice cream place.
Brandon Thomas
Handels ice cream made me feel like I was back in my home town on a summer day eating ice cream with my family. It has that sort of "town feel" that comes with affordable ice cream, good ice cream and outdoor seating. The options are far and wide from a ton of flavors and blizzards, cones, malts etc the way you get your order here truly can suit your need.
Vivian Thompson
This picturesque ice-cream parlor is an absolute gem! The ice cream here is unbelievably good, with a perfect balance of creaminess and sweetness. We opted for the 4-flavor sampler, and every single scoop was a delightful surprise. From the rich graham variant to the heavenly chocolate with peanut butter, each flavor was a taste bud's dream come true. Don't miss out on this ice cream paradise!
Kaitlyn Eaves
Chocolate cake batter is my favorite, but I do enjoy trying different flavors. They have so many to choose from. My favorite place to go for a frozen treat.
Chase Owens
I love Handel’s homemade ice cream! Banana Split hurricane is my go to choice! Their milkshakes are absolutely huge. Their hot fudge brownie sundae is also huge and delicious.
Derek Fraley
This is always the pla e I come for ice cream. It's not store bought, and it's hand-dipped, not that soft serve stuff. There are always lots of flavors and always a different flavor of the month.
Author Keynote Minister Joe Woodley
The lines of salivating customers are always long in the evening. So, I needed to see what all the fuss is about.
Now, I completely understand.
I love the large selection of unique flavors and product selections.
You'll find something you love, too.
P.S. I always get the four scoop sampler.
brandi N
Love that it's open late and all year round. The ice cream is delicious and so many flavors to choose from. The chocolate peanut butter brownie flavor was to die for and the apple dumpling was delicious
Ryan McWhorter
Great ice cream, good prices. Gets a little busy but their service is really good. The kids love it
Jessica Tackett
The ice cream here is really amazing, and they have new rotating flavors every few weeks or so. I've lived near the shop in Hilliard for a couple of years and never tire of it. I always make a point to have any who haven't had it, try it!!
Nancy Rhynard
And the Ice Cream! Not heavily sweet, very creamy with lots of flavor. It is perfect.
Richard Durflinger
Best ice cream place around. They need to keep Grape on the menu year round though. That’s an original flavor from Youngstown and you can’t find it anywhere else.
Dan Lester
Handel's has the best ice cream, at 9:15pm there were 20 people in line in front of me, but don't let the line scare you it goes pretty fast and, in my opinion, well worth it. I had a orange sherbert parfait, it was excellent. Also picked up a pint of butter pecan to keep in case I don't want to walk over. Good variety, most things are excellent. Love good fresh ice cream. If you go there enjoy it.
David Buckley
Best Ice Cream period! Always soft and taste great. I suggest the chocolate pecan. ďż˝
Andrew Queler
We love handles ice cream. It's not only the best ice cream in Ohio but the staff is always friendly and the atmosphere is always perfect for a trip and treat for the whole family....
Charles Trudeau
A great place to get a cone or shake on a warm evening
Danny Ray Steele
Delicious ice cream! Always worth the wait.
Jessica Stewart
Best place around to get ice cream hands down! It delicious and the people are always friendly!
Karen Lombard
Stopped for ice cream last night. Was surprised we weren't the only ones there on a cold night. That's how good Handel's ice cream is. It doesn't matter what the temperature is, it's always time for Handel's.
Erin Clayton McLean
So good! Huge cones, great ice cream flavors. It was hard to choose which flavors to try, will definitely return so we can try other options.
Angela Gatliff
Always love this place. Tasty ice cream. My dogs love the little puppy ice cream they sell as well
Katie Rizco
Yummy, fast and friendly service! Thank you!
Moishe Okunov
These guys are the best of the best when it comes to quality and costumer service. A+++
Liraz Blank
Definitely our family favorite! Especially their custom birthday cakes ďż˝
Joni Salmon
Had my first experience today, and it was awesome! There are so many options, and you can tell that it's quality ice cream! The customer service was wonderful as well- we will definitely be coming back for more.
Katie Strader
I'm so glad I finally found Handel's Ice Cream! I tried a sampler of the Chocoholic Chunk, Black Raspberry Chunk, Salty Caramel and Peach! All flavors were amazing and I can't wait to return! Seems like a good idea to call and pre-order pints of ice cream so they're ready for pickup when you arrive.
Jeff Zoller
Been going to this store since it opened.. once stood in line to get ice cream while it was snowing.
Cathy Hartley Duncan
I love this place. Best ice cream in Columbus ❤️💋
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes