Sluurpy
Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best New York Style Pizza in Columbus

There are 2 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Johnny's New York Style Pizza
90/100 (1235 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
New York Style Pizza
Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Johnny’s never disappoints! Fez was great! The Meat deluxe was on point And my daughter tore up the spaghetti! I’ll definitely recommend to..."
Jennifer Biggers
"It’s just the best pizza in town. Great service. Fast. A little treasure that’s hidden but oh so delicious..."
Linda Dillard
"I'm from NY and this is by-far the closest thing to NY pizza I have ever found outside of the Tri-State area. Awesome and I will be back for..."
Charles Comfort Jr
"The place by far some of the best pizza in..."
Trevor Kibler
"We ordered online, they said pick it up in 30 minutes. We did just that! It was pizza perfection, hot and ready to go. I love ordering online ,pay..."
Kathy Leeper
"Loved my Stromboli! They have a good selection on the menu. I look forward to going back and trying the..."
Sharon Pollock
"Been going to Johnny's for some time now. Greatest and best tasting pizza in the City of..."
David Phillips
"Our favorite go to place for Italian & pizza - on a weekly..."
Melinda Friesen Fuller
"My husband and I stopped by traveling through town today for the first time. The Stromboli we ordered was fantastic! What impressed us most, however,..."
Jennifer Williams
"Food is always delicious. The Johnny's special calzone and meatballs are to die..."
Lisa Parsons Smith
"Been going there since they opened! Favorite garlic knots and large pepperoni pizza � fresh hot all the time and they rock! Great people great..."
Joy Marchbanks
"Best pizza and calzones around, so fresh and delicious. Wait staff is great too. Worth the wait for a freshly made..."
Donna Goodwin Dickson
"We chose this randomly. And we did not regret it. The food and the service were..."
Angela Cross
"Very best pizza around! Great service, atmosphere, you will not be disasppointed! Real Italian dishes that are..."
Linda C Luttrell
"One of the few places my whole family can agree to eat at! It's always an enjoyable..."
Bobby Ratliff
"Great staff, awesome pizza! Give it a shot. Live..."
Justin Jodo Creed
"Good Pizza and EXCELLENT Calzone. Pretty cool atmosphere. Check it..."
Chris Fluharty
"My husband and I went for our 20 year anniversary! We enjoyed our slices! Server was great! We will definitely go..."
April Wofford
"As usual the slice was fresh and delicious. The salad was fresh and hit the..."
Ed Fuller
"Thank you for letting us celebrate my daughter's 4th birthday today! Pizza is her fave, and Johnny's has become her place of choice to endulge! Tori..."
Tamara Reyes
"Delicious as usual. Great..."
Audrey Hall Bergeron
"Closest thing to my hometown as you can get for pizza..NYC would be..."
Anthony Rolon Ortiz
"Great pizza and fantastic service. Caitlin is highly recommended by..."
Kyle Romine
"Very professional, great service, best pizza in Columbus,..."
John Bookout
"Reminded me of being home in NYC....delicious pizza and cannoli! Happy Italian woman and the server was awesome! Very sweet and..."
Catherine Stephanie Bagarella
"Love their Lasagne! It's sooooo cheesy and..."
Bea Glenn
"Awesome Food, Great Staff, and the best lunch special in..."
Nathan Thompson III
"This was our first time eating from this restaurant. We ordered our pizzas to-go. These pizzas were amazing!!! They were so delicious and so fresh..."
Kristin Colburn
"Excellent food and the service was great…the best pizza I have had in a while…thumbs up and 5 stars for Johnny’s definitely..."
Nelson Jaramillo
"Pizza it very good pastas not too good calzone excelente totally recommended for pizza and..."
Jonyisa SAN
"My first time eating here at Johnny's New York Style Pizza, and I enjoyed it. The food and atmosphere was very nice. And our server really was..."
Mary Davis
"When our Grandsons visit, Jonny's pizza is one our favorite places to meet papa for lunch! The one slice 🍕 is perfect for us! Sweet service and..."
Lisa Summerlin
"Stopped in for a late lunch and we each ordered the Italian Special. Cooked to order and was very good. Clean and accommodating with plenty of seats...."
Kevin Lee Jackson
Borgata Pizza Cafe
85/100 (1845 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Wine Bar
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Wings
Meatballs
Cannoli
New York Style Pizza
Pesto
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Wine Bar
Pizza
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Seating
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
"This. *This* should be the first thing that comes to mind when people ask you to describe the perfect pizza. - The crust is foldable, and has that..."
Darren Coykendall
"The best pizza in Columbus!!! Ordered through prime now.... It was amazing NYC pizza. The fresh baked Italian bread and oil dipping sauce was also to..."
Valerie Snyder
"Loved this place. The pizza was delicious!!! They are also excellent with people who have food allergies and restrictions. I would recommend..."
Kevin Lee
"Best pizza and excellent service, my favorite is the Mediterranean roasted vegetables pizza, Menu is complete from starter, salad, sandwiches, pasta..."
Sylvie Ouellette
"We dined at the new Worthington location today. We've eagerly been awaiting opening day and it was worth it! The cavatelli and the marinara sauce are..."
Miranda Yoder
"Lived for 8 years in NY and this is the best pizza outside of the 5 boroughs!!!! Thank you so much!!! I've been there two times in a week and I'm..."
Tanikka C. Price
"This is my favorite pizza place!!! The service is always great and the food and portions are excellent!! I tell everyone about this..."
Jessica Fraley
"Pizza is amazing, customer service even better. Nice clean environment with friendly staff. I will highly recommend this place to anyone who loves..."
Alex Simpson
"Honestly, the BEST Italian food anywhere. You have to try the sausage stuffed cubanelle peppers, loaded with sauce and cheese. We had the supreme..."
James Hott
"Six stars! I was in town visiting my dad, and my sister and I found this place on Trip Advisor. Chef Horacio was kind enough to open an hour early..."
Steve Kisslinger
"I have lived a few blocks away from this gem for nearly 4 years Now and drive by it several times a week. Always thinking to myself, I need to try..."
Tina Burns
"My favorite place to bring friends and family for authentic, fresh, homemade Italian food.... the lemon ricotta cake is truly life..."
Felicia Bisconti
"Sooo good!! We have been on the hunt for the best pizza and so far Borgata's takes the pie! They also have pretty good gluten free crust which can..."
Alexia Andrade
"We were welcomed so nicely, whole staff is sweet, funny and helpful. Pizza is amazing, we got the 20in and my husband was in heaven. The crust is..."
Mykell Merrill
"we arrived around 5pm, not too busy we sat and were greeted by our waitress, who was super friendly by the way. we ordered a couple of drafts and..."
stephen m
"Boy did we have a feast! The pizzas are huge and 5-6 people could easily have eaten off the appetizer and entree shown. The sauces and breads were..."
Ms Davis
"Not a horrible neighborhood, but certainly not the best either. I grabbed a slice and added pepperoni and banana peppers. The toppings were 75 cents..."
D Jackson
"It was good. It reminded me of pizzas east/northeast of Central Ohio. The toppings were tasty and the canned mushrooms were good as well as the..."
Michael Schriml
"The pizza here was delicious! The crust was crispy but the pizza itself was chewy and amazing. We got a large and boy was it large! The staff was..."
Vy D
"You may have a little trouble finding this place but the food is absolutely worth it. My family and I ordered the garlic cheese bread, buffalo wings,..."
Sam Childers
"Best gluten free pizza I’ve ever had - and I’ve had a lot. Best is that after eating here three separate times, I’ve never been sick. I will..."
Jackie
"Best pizza around. I'm from NY and this is by far the closest pizza place around that reminds me of home! The staff is amazing. Everyone is..."
Ameenah Ahmad
"Borgata’s has THE best sausage stuffed cubanelle peppers in the city! Served with a spicy marinara and melted cheese. Mmmmm… The crusty Italian..."
Craig Corson
"First time having this pizza, and it will absolutely not be the last. It was so delicious, we ate it in the car in the parking lot and I couldn’t..."
Brooke Olson
"Best pizza I've ever had. Will be sure to go back when I'm in the Columbus area again. Would be worth the drive from Canton for this pizza alone!!..."
Alexis H
"Pizza in Columbus is so hit and miss. If you don’t care for the square cut round pizza thing, you really don’t have many options. Borgata..."
Gregg Sayers
"We met chef Roz and what a wonderful gentleman he is. The quality of the pizza, crust, and the ingredients were top notch! He told us that they..."
Ladan B
"Forgot to take a picture because we were hungry and everything was so delicious! We went earlier this week and were greeted by the owner/chef who..."
Cyrelia J
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use