My page
Exit
×
×
Reset
There are 9 restaurants
Cuisine
Dietary restrictions
Meals
Structure
Dishes
Home
Restaurants in United States
Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Colchester
There are 9 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Roving Feast
100
/100 (0 ratings)
Restaurants
Fusion
Italian
Barbecue
American
Barbecue
Mediterranean
Italian
Mediterranean
Fusion
American
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sit down
American
Barbecue
Mediterranean
Fusion
Italian
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Jess and her team catered our wedding in August 2021 at Sunset Vistas in Alburgh, VT. As a couple of self-proclaimed foodies planning a wedding from..."
Chantal Girard
"Jess & her team served the most delicious meal for myself & my family during our small, quaint wedding in Fairfax, VT. The planning and menu..."
Charlotte Buchanan
"Jess and her team recently catered our parent's anniversary party. They did an amazing job from beginning to end. Everything was presented..."
cara holdman
"The Roving Feast is sure to please! Jess and her team prepared such incredible food including chicken, steak, and mixed veggies for our mid-day..."
Jamie Brooks
"We worked with Jess and her staff at the Roving Feast for our wedding catering, and they knocked it out of the park! From our initial conversations..."
Kelsey Ray
"We recently had the pleasure of working with Jess and The Roving Feast. They catered my 65 person baby shower and did an amazing job. Everything was..."
Becca Rydell
"First time ordering, friendly, professional! Food was amazing,tasty,presented so well,so easy to heat and..."
Deb Thayer
The Plum Tomato
90
/100 (1312 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
American
Vegan Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Lunch
Dinner
Salad
Wings
Sit down
Italian
American
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"THE STAFF HERE ARE ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!!!! During the power outage, we went there to have dinner and hopefully charge a power wheel chair. The staff..."
Princess Jacqui
"Stopped in yesterday after searching online for a gluten free grinder/ sandwich .. I got the titanic turkey sandwich... It was so good! It's hard to..."
Missy Hoyland
"The pizza was amazing and the staff make it a lot of fun. I would absolutely recommend you guys to anyone who's loves awsome pizza and..."
Jay Brear
"The service was wonderful and this was the first time we have been at the plum tomato in about a year. We highly recommend the quinoa salad, the..."
April Hunt
"Amazing! Opted for GF cheesy bread appetizer & GF pizza. By far best GF crusts I've ever had! And the waitress was great, friendly & clearly knew..."
Meghan Curtin
"My boys and I go here about once a month. They have a special sometimes it's a pulled pork bbq pizza, amazing!!! Their quesadillas and fried dough..."
Nancy Groeger
"One of the best pizza places! Great to eat in or takeout! The staff is nice and the atmosphere is inviting! The pizza is delicious and the sandwiches..."
Bridget Zesut
"Wait was long but well worth it. We were a fairly large party so, it was to be expected. Everything from the Pizza, Wings, Sandwiches, fries, and..."
Margaret Rodican Hartman
"The plum is my families favorite spot! From pizza to wings to sandwiches and a unique Caesar salad it's amazing! We do take out often and dine in..."
Liz Borah
"I've always enjoy the food and service. I had each of my children's 5th birthday parties there. The kids thought making pizzas in a restaurant was..."
Michele Mildrum Deane
"PT catered a small gathering last week for our family. Everyone loved the sausage & peppers, ziti, and of course the wings and cheesy bread! My..."
Jo-Ann Teresa
"In my opinion it's the best pizza place in the Lebanon, Hebron, Colchester area. Great service, and amazing..."
James Searles
"Huge shout out to plum tomato. My boyfriend and I order take out pretty regularly, our last order was messed up- ordered and charged for a regular..."
Jessie Ortner
"Best pizza around! You can find my husband & I there every Friday! Debbie is the best!..."
Kate Yuille-Peperni
"The food here can be great but it is really hit or miss. Lately it's mostly miss. I picked up a pizza last night that was more of a cracker than a..."
Jeff D
"Staff was great and friendly! Sandwiches are HUGE! Bonus points for homemade bread. Prices are quite affordable. Decent place to check out if you..."
Liz Nitz
"While our most recent meal at the Plum Tomato was adequate, service was extremely slow to our table. We watched other folks who had come in well..."
peter myers
"Excellent pizza! The crust had a nice crisp but also had some chew to it which I liked. I got a large and had left overs for 3 days! Well worth it..."
Steve Sparks
"The wings were awesome. Nice and crispy outside, juicy on the inside and tossed to near perfection in teriyaki. Waitress was on her game, and I..."
Joseph Grenier
"If everything in a pizza place can be judged by the cheese pizza, The Plum Tomato is One of the best wood fired pizza places in CT. I really like the..."
Darren Dyke
"Their cheese pizza slices are Awesome sauce. 😎 They have a great recipe in our family's opinion that makes it worth a stop for takeout pizza..."
Amy DesRoches
"First time trying this restaurant, the menu looked great. Ordered the Greek salad and the vegetarian chili. I must say the food was 10/10. probably..."
Cloudk-9
"Very good dinner! The chicken sandwich was huge. I ordered a quarter and it was the size of a whole at other place, fanatic taste and loaded with..."
Justin Hall
"The Plum Tomato recently catered our special event Friday night in Colchester. Worked with Erin Walls and her service was exceptional and thoroughly..."
Tracy S
"Good pizza but the only problem is when taking out it doesn't seem to.hold its heat even for a short distance. We really like the Pisa pizza and the..."
Megan Fox
"Just a short time in Colchester, but after eating at the "Plum" we are impressed. Friendly service, good and plenty food ( enough pasta to have a..."
Gerta Duncan
"I would have posted pics of the food but my stomach couldn’t wait! Absolutely amazing food whether you get pizza, a sandwich, salad, soup or..."
B C
"We used Plum Tomato Colchester Catering for our party. Everyone loved the food. Our experience in making the food order and having it delivered was..."
Maggie Murphy
Nu Nu's Bistro
86
/100 (567 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Lunch
Dinner
Shrimp
Pasta
Salad
Clams
Mussels
Polenta
Hanger steak
"This place has authentic, homemade Italian food. This place is BYOB. I had the Nu Nu's Marinara pasta and it was delicious with a ton of flavor. I..."
Nicole B
"Great restaurant. Very good service. We had the Cod Francais, which was a special, got it with side of pasta, oil and garlic. Excellent entree, one..."
Jack Kohanim
"Great food, great cozy atmosphere. BYOB and try something you've never had before like kangaroo, bison or ostrich! They have all the classic Italian..."
Nuno Bernardino
"Each and every experience at Nu Nus has been special. Typically, they have unique he dishes that are full of taste. Even the customers are nice. On..."
Christopher Coutu
"What a fantastic place. Definitely a gem for locals who filled this restored carraige house for their family Easter celebrations. BYOB, and call..."
Shane White
"Nunus is fantastic... since Jack's nephew took over the place has really modernized! The food is still fantastic, the new chef does a great job of..."
Jonathan Lane
"A little pricy (expect to drop 60 for 2 with tip), but really good food. The steak with gorgonzola was excellent, and you gotta love giving your biz..."
Ajay S
"How have Inlived in this town my entire.life and not tried the food here? The brunch was excellent. Great atmosphere. Food delish. Good price. Well..."
Deanna A
"What a great find ! Food, atmosphere and service where terrific. Very laid back and relaxing. I kinda like the byob thing..."
DAVID FLYNN
"Always a favorite in the Colchester area for Italian and just good food. Have also eaten the Sunday brunch which I rate very high. And an added bonus..."
Cliff Graillat
"Excellent food. Relaxed vibe in a historic house. Can be a noisy room but that's people enjoying life .... our favorite for years..."
Jay Carey
"A hidden gem in Colchester. The atmosphere is old town rustic and the food is authentic Sicilian. Absolutely..."
Ann Burke
Cafe Mangia
86
/100 (498 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Lunch
Brunch
Dinner
Bolognese
Cannoli
Shrimp
Pasta
Salad
Risotto
Salmon
Polenta
Meatballs
"Fantastic fare in a more intimate setting. Would recommend to anyone who's in the mood for some good Italian..."
Ryan Cosgrove
"I ordered the basil pesto rigatoni. It was a cream sauce with artichoke hearts and sun dried tomatoes. Your choice or protein. It was delicious and I..."
Tyler
"Great little place!! The lunch menu is a perfect size, not too much to choose from so what they make is PERFECT. meat ball grinder was some really..."
J & J Garcia
"Wonderful atmosphere and wait staff. I had a Great salad with salmon. The salmon could have been better. The wine choices were good. All in all,..."
Sheila Tennyson
"The food was delicious. The service was fantastic. It's a bit pricey, and the menu isn't very extensive, but I enjoyed it. They didn't seem to mind..."
Ivy Smith
"Good food, nice warm feeling inside. Doesn't look too inviting from the outside but quite nice and comfortable inside. They have an enclosed patio..."
John Bogs
"An easy pick for lunch, perfect menu to choose from. Went for the tuna melt this time and it was tasty! Parking might be tricky if you are not..."
Thelma Culver
"Cafe Mangia prepared for me a catered spread for about 30 people. Process was very simple, food was ready right on time, and every dish was..."
Craig J
"I was introduced to Cafe Mangia by a friend after we biked the Airline Trail on a Sunday. We each ordered a meatball with red sauce appetizer along..."
Don Weller
"Fantastic food, quiet atmosphere, but we were there late lunch, with super & personal service. They do each aspect of the meal thoughtfully which..."
Mike “SpikeNhammer” Fields
"I arrived around 230 and no one made me feel guilty about coming so close to the end of lunch. Heather was my server, she was prompt and friendly. ..."
stephen spranzo
"We had a delightful meal on the porch tonight! There was a slight problem with our order, but it was dealt with such finesse that it quickly became..."
Pam Penfield
"The service and atmosphere was great! My wife had a chicken parmesan that was a good portion, but was a little bland. I had a chicken picatta that..."
George Boras
"World class service. Hands down one of the best Italian restaurants. There menu is seasonal so there is always something new. The specials change all..."
Timothy Brooks
Papa-z's Pizza
80
/100 (451 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Lunch
Dinner
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"A very unassuming place. Do NOT be surprised because the food is totally amazing! My wife had a prime rib dinner that she said was as good as any..."
Kevin Fitzpatrick
"I truly love this place. Food is awesome, prices are good, staff is friendly and the owners treat you like family! Can't ask for..."
Karen Levesque Talbot
"Thank you Papa Z for putting together that lasagna yesterday! it brought Comfort to a family of friends everyone loved..."
Janet M Swider
"The chicken carbonara us a must try Has nice atmosphere and friendly wait..."
Fran Riel
"Love this place.Great food great service great..."
Diana Zuckerman
"Wonderful staff and delicious food! Always our Go..."
Sara Nicole
"The best place to eat in Colchester area from pizza, subs, pasta, seafood, steaks, and much more nothing but the BEST..."
Vasilios Spiliopoulos
"The food was amazing. Great friendly service..."
Kayla Sypek
"From the food to the service, everything is good at Papa..."
Randy Oliver
"There was a party of 7 of us. Our waitress was Kylie or kayla, sorry. She was an excellent server. I ordered a Greek salad (large), which was a very..."
Denise Millane
"Low key Greek pizzeria with typical food for this type of restaurant. Staff was friendly and attentive. Interesting variety of..."
Paul Kerswill
"I eat here all the time. Really really good food. Just got their clam strips and I am blown..."
Pervis Maxwell
"Food was good and fresh. Service was slow. Staff was..."
Alison Nelson
"I miss this place. This was always a number 1 go to for food with my family and I. The food is excellent, and the service is even better. Always..."
Kevin M. (‘LSUKEV318’)
"Our server was excellent. Food was delicious. Very family friendly. Will definitely..."
Brian Sanderson
"Excellent, delicious pizza! This is my favorite place in the general area for pizza. Do not miss their tasty cannolis either. Everything is fresh...."
Andrea Murray
"3 times in the last month have had take out pizza and grinders for lunch. Yummy! Staff is polite and attentive. Personally love the vegetarian..."
Robbin G
"Stopped for a burger for lunch on a Saturday. Had the onion, mushrooms and Swiss burger with fries. Asked for medium and was amazed to get it cooked..."
David Naismith
"Went in for a quick bite under a time constraint with the three kids, and we had our food and drinks on the table in under 10 minutes. Atmosphere was..."
Bridget Erlandson
"I was part of a large group which can be tricky. However, the ladies that took care of our group were excellent! Friendly, courteous and..."
Marie Paisley
"The food and the service are great. It's owner operated and you can tell the family cares about its..."
Steven Martorelli
"We actually got to sit on the dining room on the left side the extra room in it was great the waitress was..."
Trudy Holliday
"Delicious! Steak, seafood, pizza. Wine and beer menu. Great place for lunch or dinner. Recommend swordfish and prime rib on specials..."
Mary Ciezynski
"The pesto special pizza is so..."
M. M. Deane
"After reading the reviews, my husband and I decided to give it a try. He ordered the salmon with dill sauce, and I have shells with meat sauce. The..."
Sue Macdonald
Zachary's Pizza House
77
/100 (392 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Dinner
Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Simple CAN be better!. I HAVE to add my 2-cents because all you ever see for reviews are the BAD ones (and that's not fair.) Zachary's Pizza House in..."
Chantal H.
"I have visited this location many times and look forward to many more visits. For a quick bite, romantic dinner or easy take out I have never had a..."
Wolf Tyndall
"Very nice service. I have done take-out, delivery and dine in. We landed after long flight and they had our order ready for us to take. After a late..."
M&D Couture
"When we've been in it's been quiet, lighting and decor in the bar twinkly and relaxing, we love it. Service, food and drinks all great..."
Joannah Camper
"Very good pizza and customer service. They were very..."
David Pecor
"We eat there at least once a week and have never ever had a problem, they really go out of their way to serve us. When we order the Joanne salad,..."
Larry Gaudette
"Mallets Bay Zachary's is amazing...staffing issues but the staff that is there hustles and is smiling and courteous through it all. Great food,..."
D K
"Ive been ordering a lot from here, their spinach and artichoke dip is good (I prefer it with chips instead of the bread) and they're the only pizza..."
Josh S
Illiano's Pizzeria & Restaurant
75
/100 (370 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Lunch
Dinner
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Delivery
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The food here is amazing!! This was the first time I have been here. Mac & Cheese pizza😋 Veggie pizza 😋 Garlic Knots 😋 (very 🧄 ie..."
Holly Swiatek
"Very friendly staff. Reasonable prices but there was hardly any veal on the veal parm. Either get smaller rolls or put on more meat. The roll was..."
Tina
"We love this place! Their pizzas are so so good! We order here about once a month and they haven't let us down yet. Try buffalo chicken..."
amber cromeenes
"Driving thru Colchester.. Stumbled upon this great restaurant. Google reviews were good decided to try.. No regrets!!! Yummy food.. Great service!!..."
Sally's RockinEats
"Great service! Our waitress was wonderful and helpful with our time schedule. My side salad was amazing with crumbled blue cheese. That may sound..."
Erica Swan
"Some of the best pizza I have ever..."
joseph behm
"Edit: keeping it 5 stars for now as everyone has a bad day but pizza today has a different kind of cheese on it and it is a huge step backwards. ..."
Dave Baker
"My family and I have been eating at this chain of establishments for a great many years. Here, you are always greeted and treated like family. The..."
Michael Tucker
"It was great to dine in. Took my granddaughters for dinner. Service was friendly and personal. One of my granddaughters loves mac and cheese with..."
Ken Martin
"We ordered a large pizza that consisted of onions, mushrooms, peppers, sausage and hamburger. The pizza was very good but the cost was $33. We were..."
Bonnie Therrien
"My favorite Italian restaurant. I love their spaghetti with meatballs. The garlic knots are to die for. They're golden brown covered in minced garlic..."
Karen Smith
"Rushed into this place for a quick lunch because my mom said they sell pizza by the slice. Accidentally found my favorite pizza place in CT (well,..."
Diana Giulietti
"The pizza is light, crispy and full of flavor. Their sauce is fantastic and the service is quick and polite. I went with two friends for pizza before..."
Eva
New York Pizza Oven
75
/100 (663 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Deli
Pizza
Deli
Italian
Lunch
Dinner
Wings
Sit down
Pizza
Deli
Italian
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Accepts American Express
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"NYPO is great 18" New York Style Pizza, with wings, salads, pasta dishes and hot and cold..."
Kevin Dufresne
"Great place and we eat here frequently. There are a few problems such as the delivery to our house a few times resulting in the complete destruction..."
A Random Person
"Me and my co workers order from here every Thursday! Great Philly cheese best in the area and free fries on Thursday. Great customer service and..."
Reggie Allen
"Solid pizza overall. Very good pepperoni pizza. Specialty pizzas okay but can't go wrong with a classic pepperoni from New York Pizza Oven. Crust is..."
Samuel Coleman
"BEST PIZZA,SO FAR IN THE WINOOSKI,COLCHESTER AREA,,ALSO,VERY GOOD PRICE DID I MENTION AWESOME..."
Richard Romero
"Great food but very disappointed with the tonight’s visit! First, I was told 35 min wait for pizza pickup but ended up waiting over an hour! I..."
Micaela Kirk
Amato's
73
/100 (132 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Italian
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"It was pretty decent for gas station..."
Sarah Simoneau
"They are good. I like the pizza and bread sticks. Ordering at the counter is better than the already cooked stuff. Can be a little..."
Jenn Lee
"It is good place to..."
Son Thanh Xa
"I mean I didn't eat there but Google told me too review it. Must be good if it got..."
Hugh Wallace
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred!
Please try again in a few minutes
Sign in with Facebook
Sign in with Google
Sign in with Apple
By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
-
Privacy policy
-
Terms of use
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes