Dexter Christian
I've had many pizzas from many places but New York City Pizza is some of the best. Service was good, ⭐5 stars
Tom Jackson
We loved the outdoor bar area , our bartender was great she was from new York and recently moved to Hilton Head island
Mary Oneill
Great pizza and great supporter of Camp Leo 2019 the annual camp for blind kids from all over South Carolina enjoying all that Hilton Head has to offer.
Pat Losack
Pizza was excellent. Service was questionable. We ordered Clam Fritters they brought us Fried Calamari and tried to tell us it was clam fritters, crazy. We did not get charged for the fritters and they took the calamari away, which was strange. Did not offer for us to keep it. However the new bartender was a bright spot in the area of service. 3/17/2019 7pm.
Jeremy Whitehead
I'm a pizza snob. My wife usually has to convince me to get pizza. THIS was impressive! We got a meatlovers deep dish. Usually that's a pretty greasy pie. Not so with this one. It had a really nice, crisp crust. The top wasn't greasy and had lots of good flavor.
The staff was super friendly and chatted with us. Not a single thing to dislike here. A solid 5 star experience. Good Job guys!!
Rob Wilson
Visiting HHI for the week and decided to place a To Go order of meat lovers pizza on NY crust and garlic & parmesan wings. Arrived earlier than the amount of time they had told me the order would take and it was ready to go! Pizza was great, though my wife didn't care for the Italian sausage. But she usually doesn't like it anyway. More for me if she picks it off! The wings were disappointing to me as they were basically just fried wings with what appeared to be a bit of grated parmesan sprinkled on that easily fell off. If there was garlic, I didn't really notice it. They were still tasty and worth eating. Maybe try a different flavor for better results.
Mary Jo
What a great place for Happy Hour with co-workers. Meghan made sure our drinks and food got to us asap..PLUS she gave special attention to the special needs adult in our party....we even got Halloween Treats!!! AND NO PROBLEM WITH SEPARATE CHECKS!!!The pizza,salads and nachos were great. We loved the $4 happy hour prices!!!! You can't beat the view,the food and drinks and the best waitress in Hilton Head!!!!
Palosh Family
Great pizza restaurant in a sweet location across from the park! We visited on a busy Saturday night and the service was great - friendly waitress and fast service! The pizza the spot after a day on the beach.
For Pokemon players - you can get the Pokestops and the Poke Gym from inside the restaurant! :)
Phillip Biffle
Outstanding pizza. Great service. NY Sicilian style.
Ng Flow
I greatly appreciate the atmosphere of the restaurant. The staff is very friendly and attentive. The food is fast, fresh and good. I highly recommend the outside bar, the bartender Alicia possesses a sense of humor and is knowledgeable of specialty drinks.
Ramon Maisonet
For starters I'm from Brooklyn. So when I walk into a joint called New York City Pizza, I have very HIGH expectations. While I can't put this pizza on the same level as NY, it is delicious with very good flavor, a good mixture of spices and it's packed with cheese. Definitely would hit this place up if I came back to Hilton head.
Spiro Telegadis
Good pizza and Calzone. Beers are inexpensive compared to NYC that is for sure. Not quite NYC grade but pretty close. Definitely the best pizza in Hilton Head and SC until you reach Charleston.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes