Traveling through. Saw on TripAdvisor because I wanted cookies. A must place to stop and they will mail! Melt in your mouth, delicious, flavored perfectly. Super friendly staff and very helpful! Had samples first. Sold after first bite! �����
I absolutely Love this place! Since we live almost 5 hours away I'm glad I can order them online! Not only are their cookies amazing and the best I've had, their staff is awesome as well! Kristy, you are a gem! My daughter who is autistic talked your ear off yesterday Lol and you just listened and smiled and conversed with her. It really made her day and mine as well! Thank you for being you!
The cookies quite pricey but delicious. Love the atmosphere and staff are nice and friend. They sure give few samples to try which one you would like. Ill get some more of them next time.
Though it is a bit pricy, these cookies are definitely worth it! We got Tower Special, with the original, oatmeal raisin, snickerdoodle, lemon, and chocolate chunk. Definitely a thing to try if your in town!
The cookies are so yum. They melt in your mouth and are full of flavor. It's in a great location within walking distance of the beach. It was fast and easy. We bought the cookie tower which had 4 different types of cookies: chocolate chunk, oatmeal raisin, snickerdoodle, and sugar. It also included 3 or 4 of their signature brown butter cookies and cocoa.
Saw this place on an episode on YouTube for Roy's World on Valley PBS (happy plug for the show!). Tiny place, big kitchen. I sampled the original cookie, and although it's not my "jam" it was really good. My daughter bought several 3 and 6 packs for friends. This was our first time here, replacing our normal stop in Solvang. Cookies seemed to be more "premium" than the standard dutch/danish style butter cookie, so my daughter was a bit disappointed in how few you got for the money (in comparison). I'm sure we will be back
I visit this place every time I come out to the Morro Bay area! The cookies are to DIE for, & definitely worth the trip to Cayucos! ❤️
Great find on our way to Morro Bay. They had free sample tasting and we bought the cocoa and espresso cookies. Very delicious!
This was our first time shopping at Brown Butter Cookie Company. It is a convenient location in downtown Cayucas. There is parking in front of the store and across the street. No masks are required. The gals upfront were very friendly, cheerful and helpful. Daphne at the order counter was excellent. She answered our questions. Placed our selections very carefully into the cellophane bag. The cookies look so yummy. Farron the cashier was excellent as well. It was very unusual to see ladies in back of the cashier at tables hand rolling the cookie dough into balls. Gives it a special touch.
Outstanding cookies, staff very friendly and helpful. The only issue is trying to figure out what cookie or cookies to buy since they are all so good
Good cookies. Expensive but it is inline with cost of everything else in this tourism driven Cayucos. You can sample just about all the flavors before you buy. 4 limited edition flavors rotate every 3 months
You need to stop by and try their cookies. This place is a legit cookie house. Every cookie is make fresh herre. You can see the worker rolling the cookie dough by hand. The place smell awesome. The workers are really nice, and let you samples their freshly baked cookies.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Cayucos
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes