Yum yum. I’m usually into just chocolate and rich flavored gelato but this place has me addicted on even their fruity flavors Pineapple and lemon cookie are to die for and the gal working behind the counter was a Sweetheart Def a new Indy hot spot for cold treats
Delicious gelato! The flavor is so pure and decadent. Friendly staff. Thanks for the treat!
My boyfriend and I love everything from here! I ordered the meatball sandwich. It was pure bliss! The desserts are absolutely delicious! Some were a perfect blend of creamy and nutty! Others were beautifully fruity and herbal! We also enjoyed dairy-free dark chocolate ice gelato with fresh espresso brewed on top! I'm obsessed! The service was amazing! We will definitely be regulars here!
This place is the best! Homemade everything! Cannolis are my absolute favorite and they deliver! Next time I’m ordering the pizza and meatball sub. What a hidden gem.
They are so wonderful! Definitely get in for the Italian hot chocolate. They have a lactose free option as well. We bought one of each of the cannolis. They are divine! They have a huge selection of Italian goodies and food. Pizza and sandwiches, cakes and cookies.
Christine & Lucio are amazing! We had them cater our wedding and the food was outstanding . Our guests continue to tell us how good the food was. The presentation was amazing and the service Five Star! We cannot say enough good things about Stacco house .
This is a staple for us when we come into the city. The best peanut butter pie, hands down. Key lime pie is outstanding. Chocolate croissants, pistachio croissants, lemon cookies, you name it it's great!
This place is worth a stop, and it's better than it's location (in the same strip mall as a gas station) would seem. The desserts are better than the food. Tried 2 types of cookies, and both were good, if not a bit heavy. The desserts certainly look fantastic, and it's clear that attention goes into the them. We will try more.
On the other hand, we tried 2 food dishes and 2 sandwiches, and all were "meh". One was too salty, another was too wet, and another had too much breadcrumb (meatballs). We thought the food prices were a bit high as well.
Christine (pastry chef) is super nice, very smiley, and very helpful.
Seating is extremely limited, so plan on carrying whatever you buy out the door.
This is a story with many chapters.
Ordered a Cheese Cake in an emergency, super fast and it was beyond anything I have ever tasted (and it was huge). Went back a week later for a coffee, unreal. Came back the next day for Cookies, the kids were begging for more. They literally ate a plate of 18 cookies in about 8 seconds while saying how great they were the whole time. FWIW, they may or may not have had a few Mom's snagging a few and nodding while claiming they weren't eating them.
I happened to see on the menu board they had pizza while picking up the cookies and ordered on a whim for dinner tonight...OMFG, it is hard to describe how perfect it was. Please for the love of all that is good support this cafe. It is simply the best food in Carmel hands down.
I'll be there this week for their Italian Beef which I haven't tried yet. Drooling already.
This unassuming little place has become a regular for us. It started with the amazing Italian cookies (lemon curd and Italian thumbprint are my faves) and breads, but then I was convinced to try the pizza by the clerk who said it was delicious. She was so right - so much so that it’s ruined all other pizza in Indy/Carmel for me. Homemade in house sauce, crunch on the outside soft on the inside crust is full of flavor and the toppings are so fresh and good. Huge slices of pepperoni, thick sausage, fresh mushrooms and super cheesy real mozzarella. Forget all your other local/regional places which are great and go here - it’s worth it!
More authentic Italian food with a fresh taste! The staff was extremely nice and helpful when making a selection. I also like how wide of a variety the desserts to choose from as well. Their cannolis are by far some of the best I have ever had. The best part is that they offer the entrees hot and ready or cold! I just know I’m going to become a regular here.
Both the pistachio gelato and shake are so good. My only complaint is the size is a bit on the smaller side given the price point.
Lots of different stuff for sale here.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Carmel
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes