Muldoon's
111 W Main St - Carmel
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#20 of 208 restaurants in Carmel
Updated on
€€
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
62/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🌳
Outdoor seating
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
🍺
Alcohol
🍹
Cocktails
🍷
Wine
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
♿
Accessible restroom
😊
Casual
🛋️
Cozy
👥
Good for groups
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
1,019
Google reviews
** Update**
We returned after a not so great visit in November. This visit was more like the Muldoon’s I know. The service was good, they were accommodating for our service dog and the food was delicious. I would put their onion rings up against anyone’s. I appreciate Muldoon’s for reaching out and being proactive after our last visit. They quickly addressed our concerns and were proactive about reaching out. While we were not planning on returning so soon, the family decided to give them a try again after spending time downtown. Glad we did!
We have always enjoyed Muldoon’s in the past. However our last visit was extremely disappointing. While eating my tenderloin, I found a long hair in my sandwich. I immediately notified our server. The lack of leadership interaction was extremely disappointing. The server was left to handle the situation herself and at no time did the manager even come to our table. The best she did was walk past our table as the server pointed out our table, quickly turn around and go back into the kitchen. *No one at our table had any hair close to the length of that found in the food*. Can only imagine she wanted to blame it on someone at our table. Wasn’t our server’s fault but to leave the server to handle bad customer experiences is definitely a sign of poor leadership. Definitely won’t be back anytime soon.
Read more
Google
Most of our group had the famous breaded tenderloin ... no one was disappointed.
Google
Our 1st time here. We shared a fish dinner & a tenderloin sandwich - both were very good. Highly recommend the tenderloin!
Google
Such a great area to grab a pint and food. I recommend stopping for a bite and sitting out on the patio. Service was very slow but friendly and the food was on point for an Irish style pub.
Google
This establishment is great. They do an incredible job hitting the Irish pub experience with incredibly made food (try the rueben) to genius, smithwicks on tap. Brenda and Dawn were absolutely incredible. Great service, great pours (yes that is a thing). Will return very soon and for a long time. Great staff.
Read more
Google
First time visit tonight and it was wonderful! The service was fantastic and food was quick and fresh. I was hesitant on getting the tenderloin because I am picky about them, but went off the recommendations from reviews and I’m so glad I did. The most tender and flavorful tenderloin I’ve had in recent memory. The cheese skewers were good as well. The spicy margarita was on point. Other people in my party got the tuna melt and the buffalo chicken salad and everyone was happy. The place was a little noisy, but that’s to be expected when a place is packed. Thank you for being an affordable, welcoming, and most importantly delicious place for us to have our early thanksgiving at!
Read more
Google
Came with a large group of coworkers for a retirement lunch and everything was perfect. I personally had the Pollos Mexicano and it was delicious!
Google
Excellent! Large portions.
First visit.
Appetizer - 9 layer dip with tortilla chips- which I Love and have never seen at any other restaurant- good taste & plenty of melted cheese!
I ordered a breaded tenderloin- Huge and good, seasoned fries are super crispy. Homemade banana cream pie- yummy & the piece was Huge, like a double slice!
Table mates: Huge BLT salad with Slices of bacon not wimpy bits & tuna melt sandwich was overstuffed, also commented the slaw was Excellent!
I'll be back!
Read more
Google
Food was good, we just had an appetizer and bloody Marys. Our server was friendly. We were here from out of town and wanted a place to watch the Bengals game, which was on at the same time as the colts. The bar was accommodating and seated all the out of town fans together in the back room with 2 TVs to watch the game. It created a great environment, even though the Bengals blew it!
Read more
Google
An excellent dining experience. Fast friendly service and tasty food. As an appetizer we got the fried cheese (and adult take on mozzarella sticks) and I got the Breaded Pork Tenderloin and my wife got the French Dip. The appetizer and sandwiches delicious. I got a Black and Tan and it was tasty as well. We would not hesitate to go back if the opportunity presents itself.
Read more
Google
Explore more in Carmel
Help improve this page: