Best Restaurants in Carlisle

Discover 240 restaurants with browsable menus, verified reviews and prices. Complete guide updated October 2026.

⭐

74/100

Avg Rating

🍴

30

Cuisine Types

20 of 240 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

The Pie Haus

The Pie Haus

💬 94 reviews

📍 46 W High St

La Villa Mexican Restaurant Of Carlisle

La Villa Mexican Restaurant Of Carlisle

💬 498 reviews

📍 30 School St

Rita's Italian Ice

Rita's Italian Ice

💬 332 reviews

📍 500 S Hanover St

Issei Noodle

Japanese Asian Vietnamese

💬 1658 reviews

📍 54 W High St

Kimball Farm

Kimball Farm

💬 895 reviews

📍 343 Bedford Rd

Fiss'

💬 507 reviews

📍 120 Highway 5

Bruster's Real Ice Cream

Bruster's Real Ice Cream

💬 319 reviews

📍 220 Penrose Pl

Coco & Nini's Restaurant & Lounge

Coco & Nini's Restaurant & Lounge

💬 228 reviews

📍 60 School St

Square Bean Coffee

Square Bean Coffee

💬 178 reviews

📍 25 W High St

Mummerts Chocolates

💬 63 reviews

📍 21 W Pomfret St

Carlisle Thai Cuisine

💬 182 reviews

📍 141 W High St

Leo's Homemade Ice Cream

Leo's Homemade Ice Cream

💬 1055 reviews

📍 816 W High St

Cafe Bruges

Cafe Bruges

Belgian Bar European

💬 1687 reviews

📍 16 N Pitt St

Vinny's Pizza & Restaurant

Vinny's Pizza & Restaurant

💬 622 reviews

📍 330 S Hanover St

Hook & Flask Still Works

Hook & Flask Still Works

💬 178 reviews

📍 137 North Hanover Street

Advada's Diner

Advada's Diner

💬 571 reviews

📍 604 Frances Street

Lili's Place

Lili's Place

💬 55 reviews

📍 10 W Pomfret St

Momma Spriggs Restaurant

Momma Spriggs Restaurant

💬 697 reviews

📍 160 York Rd

Grazery

Grazery

Mediterranean Greek Healthy

💬 399 reviews

📍 156 W High St

John's Hideaway Restaurant

John's Hideaway Restaurant

💬 363 reviews

📍 302 N College St

🍴

Explore by Cuisine Type

American 57 Fast Food 19 Pizza 17 Bar 11 Cafe 11 Italian 11 Asian 10 Diner 9 Chinese 7 Mexican 6 Pub 5 Barbecue 4 Deli 4 Japanese 4 Sushi 4 European 2 Healthy 2 Seafood 2 Soups 2 Belgian 1 Brew Pub 1 British 1 Greek 1 Indian 1 Latin 1 Mediterranean 1 Nepali 1 Southwestern 1 Spanish 1 Steakhouse 1

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📋

94 Browsable Menus

📅

Oct 2026 Last Updated