Amazing pizza and friendliest staff so hardworking! Great atmosphere and art and place! Thank you!
We ordered take out. 2 large pizzas and cheese bread.
All I can say is WOW!!! I wish we knew about this place sooner! We ordered a large pepperoni and a gluten-free pizza! Both were super delicious! Friendly service as well! We will be regulars for sure!!
The pizza was delicious and the crust was on point! We ordered it well done which made the pizza that much better. The worker was nice and hospitable. Overall, a good NY style pizza.
Great experience! We ordered three pizzas (cheese, pepperoni, sausage) and a cheesy bread. They were all ready in 20 minutes. They were a good size and tasted great. This place is underrated!
When you’re the only pizza game in a tourist town, you can make a s**t tier pizza and do well. This guy makes a great pizza. Not the best, but much better than it should be. Easily would be in rotation at home. Yeah, he’s unconventional, but if you were a pizza dude in paradise, I’m sure you’d be eccentric too.
Ordered 10 pizzas for a birthday at Tween Waters. A bit pricey, but it’s a tourist area and options are limited. Quality was pretty good and toppings were okay. If there’s limited options for Pizza on Captiva, this is a great way to go.
My friend and I ordered a mushrooms and pepperoni pizza. It was delicious!
Our family grabbed a large pepperoni and it was excellent! Fresh ingredients and huge portions. The service was amazing. He really went above and beyond.
I am providing this pizzeria five stars, not due to its customer interaction but because of its amazing New York Style Pizza. The workers odd tone on the phone had me questioning if the pizza would come to me put together and in a box. With my complete satisfaction it did, and looked and tasted amazing! “The best garlic bread” says my sister. I wanted to keep eating the pizza past the point that I should. 10/10 would recommend.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Captiva Island
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes