Pretty Tasty
31 Carpenters Lane - Cape May
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2021
#76 of 104 restaurants in Cape May
Updated on
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
72/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
📷 Photos (10)
+2
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 10
100%
Google Reviews
26
Google reviews
Happened upon this shop by accident.
As luck would have it we were in need of some gluten free cupcakes and this place came through with some of the best gf cupcakes we have had in a long time.
The owner was extremely kind an patient as our 7 year old explained exactly what she wanted and made them to her exact specifications. They looked amazing but sadly we forgot to take pictures.. they were also very delicious. They certainly live up to their name. This will become a regular stop whenever we are in Cape May!
Read more
Google
The best cupcakes!!! Owner is the sweetest person!
Google
Cute little pink shop. 🌸
Delicious cupcakes! We had the mint chocolate chip, lemonade and salted caramel. They were all very tasty.
They even had a #free britney cupcake.
The girl there was very sweet. I would highly recommend.
Google
I was looking for a place to get some cupcakes for my daughters 16th birthday and happen to find Pretty Tasty Cupcake Boutique in Cape May. I pre-ordered a dozen mix variety flavor cupcakes. The didn’t open until noon and I needed them earlier , but Erica the owner said she would come in at any that worked for me so I could pick the cupcakes up . The owner is very nice and runs great business. She told me the story how she got started 7 years ago and it so was touching how she create a great business. The cupcakes were delicious and my daughter and her friends loved them . Every variety was delicious!! They were decorated so pretty and the finishing touch of the pretty ribbon she puts on the box made it more special . Thank you Erica for making for making my first experience at your business a great experience. I will definitely be back and will recommend your cupcake bakery! Your business gives such a personal experience! Your shop is adorable too!
Read more
Google
This is the absolute best cupcake you’ll ever taste and Erica the owner is one amazing person. Do yourself a big favor and stop by to try her outstanding stuff, you will not regret it.
Google
Awesome cup cake store that is nut free. Great for people with allergies. The lady that works there is wonderful.
Google
This is a Cape May hidden gem!!! It’s right by Congress Hall and the cupcakes are absolutely delicious. I would keep coming back if I lived in Cape May. This was the perfect sized sweet treat after lunch. There were six cupcake selections to choose from. We all got something different and each cupcake was spectacular.
Read more
Google
Amazing cupcakes!! They even assured me the cupcakes had no nuts and gave me a free cupcake due to my peanut allergy.
Google
I worked in the mall last year and would frequent this place to buy cupcakes for myself and sometimes my coworkers. Not only were the cupcakes wonderful, but the owners gave me a discount upon hearing I worked in Cape May. Very kind people, wonderful cupcakes, and a lovely store overall. Definitely worth visiting if you happen to be looking for a sweet treat while in Cape May.
Read more
Google
Absolutely the best cupcakes I’ve ever had !! I am a foodie & this place is heaven on earth
Google
Explore more in Cape May
Help improve this page: