Peace Pie
326 Carpenter Ln - Cape May
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#10 of 103 restaurants in Cape May
Updated on
€€
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
70/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
♿
Wheelchair accessible
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
243
Google reviews
Phenomenal! Went to Cape May in 2022 and the filing station restaurant sold them. I had the strawberry shortcake one and it was the best ice cream sandwich I’ve ever eaten, bar none!
Google
We had salted caramel brownie and peanut butter cookie dough. Both were awesome.
Google
Peace Pie of Cape May made some good looking and delicious tasting ice cream sandwiches. The exceptional cookie crust was crispy and buttery. The pecan pie filling has me wondering if I could concoct an at-home ice cream topping this delicious. The vanilla ice cream was better than grocery store grade, but not quite as good as my favorite parlor. Overall I'd say 4.5, rounded to 5, because the cookies themselves are binge-worthy and the server was a nice young man.
Read more
Google
I got the Strawberry Shortcake and my wife got the Chocolate Raspberry. They were both super delicious. Service was very fast because they have two serving windows. Will definitely be coming here again.
Google
I had the chocolate raspberry and it was very delicious! The cookie was certainly crispy so it didn't fall apart and the ice cream some how hit the perfect middle between not too cream and not too icy. I will state it was was a little pricey $8 for one scoop of ice cream. Overall flavors and textures on point.
Read more
Google
Peace pie is a gem!! I was looking forward to visiting throughout my entire trip. The ice cream sandwiches are so delicious. They are really big, which means you can definitely share them. You used to be able to go inside, but I assume because of covid now you order through a window. We got the Elvis, salted caramel brownie, and cookie dough. They were all really delicious!!
Read more
Google
Massive ice cream sandwiches. They are so good too. Very little line as it is off of the mall. Wont stay a hidden gem for long.
Google
Stopped by Peace pie for dessert while in cape may and wow, so glad I did because it did not disappoint! Took me a while to figure out which one I wanted MOST but ended up choosing the peanut butter blondie and YUMMMM! I loved it. My boyfriend got the coconut cream and I may or may not have asked him for a bite and yup, even better (your bfs dessert always is). I would definitely return, we came in the fall so no wait, everything was quick and easy. Staff was friendly. Come by and check it out for yourself!
Read more
Google
Amazing every time! I'm always excited to come here. There are so many flavors to choose from and they are all delicious. The one pictured below is called "Fall Harvest" and it has a cinnamon cookie with pumpkin ice cream and some kind of vanilla filling with rainbow sprinkles. It was very good!
Google
Amazing ice cream sandwiches. A must stop shop when visiting Cape May! I tried the cookie dough and it was an absolute dream. I want another one before we leave!!! It's not just ice cream, but layers of cookie dough in between 2 perfect cookie shells. I never imagined a place like this. I wish it was closer to my house! Then again, I don't have the will power to not stop in every day. So the distance will spare me from becoming a diabetic. You must stop in!!!
Read more
Google
Explore more in Cape May
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: