Plus 1 Pizza
26 Olive St, 43724-1356 - Caldwell
Updated on
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
📷 Photos (10)
+2
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 10
100%
Google Reviews
96
Google reviews
I am from out of state, I usually only have dominos haha but I wanted to try something different. This is what I chose. I got the New Yorker, it was delicious. Definitely fresh. The crust is different from back home which was cool. The boneless wings tasted way better than they look so don’t let that fool you. Seems like good quality and the Buffalo sauce has a nice kick to it. I have no appreciation for weak Buffalo sauce. The brownie was warm fudgy and gooey but still with a little crunch along the edges. I have no complaints. Nobody asked me but it’s easier to enjoy things when you look on the bright side.
Read more
Google
Picked up the first one and it was wrong. Drove in snow storm for replacement and it was wrong. Pizza shop had closed by then so we had to eat the second wrong one. Very displeased.
Google
Excellent pizza ! Very tasty and well done
Google
I ordered a small pizza with extra extra sauce and even made a note in the comments to make sure they added it. Of course they didn't even add enough to taste it. This is why I haven't ordered from there in a while and I guess I'll go elsewhere from now on.
Google
I always get the Italian sub as it is very good.
Google
I have always loved Plus One. I've been ordering from this shop since I was 5 years old. They have the best ingredients, the best dough, and the best sauce in town. If you don't believe me, place an order and find out for yourself
Google
I'm staying in Caldwell because of my job. So I try a lot of different places when I work out town. This is the best pizza I've had in a while. Got it for delivery estimated was 65 minutes but it came in 20 minutes. I also got a order of wings, they wasn't as hot as I like them to be but was very flavorful. Will definitely be ordering from here again.
Read more
Google
Great food. Fast and friendly service in extremely bad weather.
Google
Explore more in Caldwell
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: