Custard Corner

I was really disappointed with the way the “Boss” of the place handle my critic. Even more dissatisfied with the way the Italian sausage was today. I asked if I can just get refunded because of the way it tasted from the one bite I took and how hard it was, not only that but I have never seen a sausage pink in the middle the way it was. The “Boss” then proceeded to say how she baked it for an hour and then grilled it, last time I check sausages can be cooked in 10-15 on a grill and not come out looking like that, Of course I didn’t take a picture before I place ketchup and Mustard on it but it definitely looked pale but I wasn’t thinking anything of it. I was going to take it back but then I realize never mind I’ll just throw it in the trash, I felt bad because I didn’t pay for it, a co worker paid for it today and I just didn’t want her money going down the drain. I would never order food from here again.

Went with a friend and ordered two scoops of a Perry's (less than $5) and it was the perfect cool down treat! The service was prompt and the staff professional. They also have an large food menu, but that will have to be for another visit/review. The parking lot can feel a little cramped, but it's a nice spot with outdoor seating.

This is the #1 spot for custard in the Greater Buffalo area, trust me here- I've been everywhere. It's worth the occasional wait in line that you may run into. There's a reason we all go here! Just be sure to order one larger than your usual size elsewhere, their small cone is more comparable to a kid's mini cone at other places. Medium is a small, etc. It's not really an issue for me, I just order a large every time now lol.

Unfortunately I will never come here again, as my family and I were waiting in line the employee shut the lights off and was very upset…. She said I’m only going to take you guys cause we are supposed to be closed already. I went to give my order and when I asked for 3 cones she rolled her eyes. I decided then to just leave and go to DQ. Horrible customer service, my family and I were very disappointed.

Review from 2021: I won’t be coming here anymore, they are more expensive every year than anywhere else, and very stingy with toppings, even after you pay extra. Consistently stingy. They have a good location and capitalize on that. Review from 2018: I come here a few times a week, and the staff are friendly, and happy to customize my ice cream orders. I find the custard better then Anderson's, and the park is nice to walk through while eating.