Atlantic Bagels Cafe

I fully admit that this is partially my fault BUT I did just pay literally 20 dollars for one bagel. It was a great bagel, don’t get me wrong, and it was was gluten free, but I feel like I should have gotten a little more warning before the bagel was made and I was at the register. Again, a great bagel, which is why I’m giving it 2 stars, but mad expensive. Gluten free-ers beware: it’s 4 dollars extra for a GF bagel

This place is a scam. They don’t have their prices posted in the store which is illegal in NY and base their prices by “customer appearance”. My daughter ordered an egg and cheese on a bagel. The price for that in the neighbourhood is between $2.50 to $3.50. Instead they charged her over $8.00! When my daughter asked why it was $8, the woman at the register said “they’re magic eggs” and laughed. It was a mediocre bland bagel, nothing special about it. My daughter was too embarrassed to tell them she didn’t want it. They took advantage and scammed her. This establishment is made up of a bunch of crooks. Avoid them unless you want to be charged double the price of every other bagel store in the area.

This is my happy place. The best value bagel in the neighborhood (literally half the price of smith or court st bagels - $15 for one?? No thanks), best TASTING spreads and salads, and the absolute kindest team. Everyone is friendly and warm. The space itself is spacious, and the delivery is quick. A true neighborhood gem! Love you guys!