THIS IS THE BEST PIZZERIA IVE EVER BEEN TOO.
10/10 Recommend. 😋
Anything and everything you eat here is the best, the quality in every ingredient, the portion size, the variety, etc.
This place is a very inviting and welcoming atmosphere, and is wonderful for people with food allergies such a gluten intolerance and other allergies.
They care for their customers, are very cleanly, and so much more.
In the pictures are: potato croquettes, Sicilian slice, mozzarella sticks, and a grandma slice. ❤️
Late on the night of Sunday, December 18, 2022, my friends and I visited Bay Ridge Pizza after touring Christmas displays in Dyker Heights. Cold, hungry and in one case, unwell, Gaspar (the owner) and Christopher both welcomed us in for an exceptional meal and great experience. At Gaspar's suggestion, we tried the Grandmother Pizza which was nothing short of divine. He and Christopher made us feel like we were at home and had a great conversation with us late into the evening. We would highly recommend both the food and staff at Bay Ridge Pizza, and will definitely visit again!
I’m gluten free and had an abundance of options to choose from, it was a harder decision than normal. One of the workers even made a special pizza with my toppings that I wanted so they catered super well. They are all friendly and have a great attitude even when we walked in one minute after opening. Highly recommended this place for gluten free people and people who love to chat with the owners.
Many Attitudes of Dennis
+4
SOLID slice, 4 out 5. It’s well balanced from tip to crust and nothing about it is wrong. With that said, for me, it does fall slightly short of just the extra special something. However, there’s enough here to make go in intending to only eat one slice but then immediately returning for a second. This pizzeria deserves its popularity. I saw a guy eating a slice while sitting in what had to be a 70s Lincoln Town Car, so they have a loyal following. I ordered a regular plain slice first, enjoyed it thoroughly, and then returned to try “a square.” The square definitely has a better more buttery crust. I like that the pricing is fair ($3) and they don’t charge extra for squares. I might not travel from Staten Island just to get their pizza, but I would definitely return if in the Brooklyn area.
Best pizza in all 5 boroughs! It’s a regular counter order pizza place but the food is amazing. There’s a reason they keep winning awards.
Pasta, pizza, vegan or GF? No problem.
Great hard working employees, clean bathrooms, fresh flowers on the tables every time :)
So happy with the dinner I had catered and delivered. Gasper was super friendly and helped me decide the perfect menu items over the phone. I’m impressed that they accommodated me the same day - without question! Quality, heart, and delicious food. Thankful for them!
One of the last great places in Brooklyn to have authentic Brooklyn pizza.
I recommend both square and round pies.
Sauce is classic, and the cheese had upheld the standards I have grown up with.
In a world where most businesses are cutting expenses, Bay Ridge pizza puts its quality over its costs.
After Leaving Brooklyn 20 years ago, and after walking up and down 5th Ave,
This was a sight for sore eyes, and a treat for lunch reminiscent of my time as a Brooklynite.
Yumm pizza indeed though the sitting isn’t really pleasant still a good place.
I am so pleased with the owners and staff at Bay Ridge Pizza, my 8 year old granddaughter has Celliac Condition and I ordered Gluten Free Pizza yesterday for her and for my family. The owner Chris let me know what the ingredients were in the pizza to make sure it would be good for her.The pizza was incredible and she loved it, we tried many other places and this gluten free was exceptional. I always order from them but never gluten free, I’m so very happy with their restaurant and how exceptional and kind they are to their customers.
This is a nice homely place and the folks there warm and friendly.
We ordered a few Vegan dishes and a few non vegan. The food was warm and delicious. The service prompt. They place chairs outside for those who would like to eat at the establishment. In all we were not disappointed with our food or the service and will stop by again.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Brooklyn
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes