Blue Marble Ice Cream

Great coffee, too. It’s worthy of being called a cafe that sells ice cream. Good space and a summer patio Editing my review to 4 stars because I feel actively hated whenever I step foot in this establishment. Come on bro lighten the mood. It’s ice cream! But probably don’t pay the staff enough. Pay them more so they smile. Idk

Reasonably good organic ice cream (12 flavors, 4 vegan) at organic shop prices ($7 for a single scoop). Really nice outdoor seating under lights and apple trees after going through inside. They also have various types of coffee and some baked goods. It felt like a progressive hip ice cream shop. Flavors included classics and a few innovative ones like Rose and bread, flagship blue marble (blue vanilla with peanut butter and marshmallow). Texture was decent, they allow sampling and staff were friendly. My favorites were the rose and bread and black raspberry with chocolate fudge. Blue marble was also quite good.

A great ice cream stop before heading for a stroll in Prospect Park. I ordered a waffle cone with a split scoop consisting of a mix between nitro cold brew and organic maple. It was quite a tasty treat, including the taste of the waffle cone. I expect this store to get busier as the weather gets warmer. I would definitely return for another treat.

Best ice cream in the neighborhood—and that’s a pretty high bar given that there are quite a few places. I live here and have tried them all. I should exercise tomorrow. Pro tip: Try their weird flavors (like cardamom or rosewater & bread!) Most ice cream makers are worried about the reception of their exotic flavors and overcompensate with excess sugar or fail to commit enough to showcasing the flavor itself. Blue Marble trusts that people who order something unorthodox either know what they want or are adventurous and aren’t afraid to be surprised. They really think about how best to formulate each flavor, and they’ve nailed everything they’ve put in their menu.

We visited Blue Marble since we saw a crowd in their outdoor dining area. People looked like they were enjoying their ice cream so much so we gave it a try impulsively. The line moved fast and the wait wasn’t too bad. The decor was adorable with color baby blue and white. The staff was friendly, attentive and recommended us her favorite flavors. We tried the Banana Cream Pie and Salt-Kissed Caramel in split single cup. The ice cream was decent but the flavors weren’t my types.