Cataldo's Restaurant & Pizzeria

554 Vanderbilt Ave # 1, 11238-3574 - Brooklyn
€€ Italian Pizza
★★★★★ ★★★★★
84/100
566 recommendations

Verified Dish

Add Missing Dish

84/100
Sluurpy Score
566 total reviews
Tripadvisor
4.5/5
39 reviews
Google
4.5/5
298 reviews
Foursquare
3.8/5
100 reviews
Zomato
3.7/5
18 reviews
Menupix
4.0/5
19 reviews
Restaurantji
4.6/5
92 reviews
🌳 Outdoor seating 🚚 Delivery 🥡 Takeout 🍽️ Dine-in 🍺 Alcohol 🍷 Wine 📅 Reservations Wheelchair accessible

💬 What people say

Italian 66 Prices 18 Vodka sauce 13 Tomato sauce 12 Wine 11 School 9 Brick oven 7 Chicken parm 6

Contact Information

📞 Phone: +1 718-857-6700
📍 Address: 554 Vanderbilt Ave # 1, Brooklyn

🕐 Opening Hours

Open now Closes at 10:00 PM
Monday1 12:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Tuesday2 12:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday3 12:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Thursday4 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Friday5 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Saturday6 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Sunday7 Closed

Google Reviews (10)

G

Gary McCrear

11 months ago
★★★★★ 5/5
I love coming to this restaurant as it is always peaceful and I can always ensure i’m going to have a wonderful experience. The service is always quick and I feel the love in every meal I have.
Google
W

Wave Yaki

a year ago
★★★★★ 5/5
Absolutely delicious, if you want a classic Italian meal this is where you go
Google
M

Megan McLarney

a year ago
★★★★★ 5/5
One of my favorite meals is a Cataldos Veal Parmigiana hero, house salad, and a cappuccino. Love sitting here for lunch, love ordering delivery for dinner.
Google
S

Sunny Regina

3 years ago
★★★★★ 5/5
We love Cataldo's! Tonight we had arugula salad, baked clams, fettuccine alfredo with shrimp, and cavatelli Pugilese (homemade cavatelli with sausage and broccoli rabe). Absolutely fresh and delicious. Sigh, and the black and white mousse dessert... yum. Always friendly service. Family owned and operated!
Read more
Google
M

Melissa O'Connor

3 years ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
Went here for dinner after our first choice had a long wait and ended up with some DELICIOUS penne vodka! Don’t come here expecting a fancy dinner, but you will get good family-style Italian cooking. Also, the prices are fantastic and don’t break the bank.
Google
T

Terrance Beckett

5 years ago
★★★★★ 5/5
Excellent food and service. If you are looking for a local, family-friendly Italian place, this is it. The lasagna is good (pictured) but my favorite might be the chicken sorrentina.
Google
J

James Caragiulo

5 years ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
Great Italian restaurant in Prospect Heights. Casual atmosphere with a nice selection to choose from. Its good for a quick sandwich to go or sit down for a nice meal. Owned and operated by a really nice and friendly family.
Google
E

Evald Tali

5 years ago
★★★★★ 5/5
Brilliant italian restaurant. Exactly what you would expect - 100% italian food. Ordered manicotti and was not disappointed! Will definitely come back again 👌🏻
Google
D

dave I

5 years ago
★★★★★ 5/5
Update 1/2018- chicken picatta w/pasta, really good and a nice portion. Wow! Really good, home cooked comfort food. Been here several times and will return many times. Friendly staff, clean and a nice spot to chill out.
Google
J

Jason Dorn

6 years ago
★★★★★ 5/5
This is truly an amazing place. Incredible Italian Food. Homemade taste like you were eating at your family's home. Excellent marinara sauce (perfect in my opinion). Sal and Russ & family really know their stuff and they treat everyone that walks in like family. They have wood fired brick oven pizza that is perfect. Usually we get the Pugliese (broccoli rabe and sausage) which is exactly what we got this time (lol). They have a lot of great pizza but that's my favorite. Fried calamari is always incredible. We also had chicken parm and penne alla vodka, and salmon with broccoli. I finished off with one of their daily specials Rigatoni Norma (rigatoni with fried eggplant and ricotta cheese). Wow it was so good i came again the same week for the same dish (and the Pugliese pizza and Fried calamari LOL). Finished off with an expresso with sambuca. I have know Sal for many years and he really knows his stuff. Pasta always al dente (little firm, which is the only way you should eat pasta), marinara sauce is always perfect (just like when mom makes it), as is everything they make there. Also, don't forget they make the best Italian sandwiches. My favorite is the mixed seafood (fried shrimp & calamari) with marinara sauce (i like it spicy so i add crushed red pepper). Good size portions and reasonable pricing make this the go to spot in the area. Try for yourself you won't be disappointed. Highly recommend. Buon Appetito!
Read more
Google

📊 Compare with Other Restaurants

Restaurant Score Google Tripadvisor Reviews
Gordo's Cantina 85% 4.6/5 4.5/5 874
Hank's Restaurant 78% 4.3/5 4.5/5 1,584
Johnny's Pizza 86% 4.3/5 4.0/5 594
Dunkin' Donuts 70% 3.0/5 3.5/5 818
Subway 70% 3.9/5 3.5/5 2,156
Taco Bell 70% 3.5/5 3.0/5 371

Other Restaurants in Brooklyn

Pita Point

⭐ 100.0 (312 reviews)

Cream Puff Cafe

⭐ 100.0 (150 reviews)

Sandwich Girl

⭐ 100.0 (140 reviews)

Caputo's Fine Foods

⭐ 100.0 (139 reviews)

Oshi's Cafe

⭐ 100.0 (127 reviews)

The Holy Grill

⭐ 100.0 (69 reviews)

Help us improve

← Back to all restaurants in Brooklyn

🍽️ Suggest a dish

⚠️ Report error

🚫 Report closed

Do you confirm that Cataldo's Restaurant & Pizzeria has permanently closed?