We went for Mother’s Day dinner. Luckily, parking wasn’t hard at dinnertime on a Sunday (I was surprised, normally the lot is terrible in Bronxville) Dinner was good and most importantly, my mom was happy lol.
Pictured: Fried stuffed mushroom app, sole & crabmeat entree and apple pie.
We went for my mothers birthday. All I can say is everything was PHENOMENAL! Our server was Mary who couldn't of been better for us from personality to service. She was like having another family member at the table. Luckily, our group ordered a variety of food so we were able to see alot of the items. I had the Lamb Stew which was tender and and packed with flavor. The wings were some of the best I've ever had, the quality of the chicken stood out. Lamb Chops were great, if you go when the have Prime Rib I recommend that too. Eat here, drink here, go here. I want to thank them for making it a memorable experience for my Mom.
Chicken soup and the scrod fish were salty. The potatoes were stale, the vegetables had a bit of freezer taste. The coffee was disappointing, but the apple pie was delicious.
Came here while visiting the NYC area. Very good food, friendly service, good price. It was nice to go out to a dinner for two and have a quality experience for less than $100.00 (including drinks!) My wife loved the Spinach Salad with Salmon, and I was pleased by a tasty Shepherd's Pie.
The restaurant also was very nicely put together with beautiful darkwood trim and moulding and backlit stained glass, but not dim or oppressive. One of the prettier places I've been in the NYC area.
Our son just started college here, so we'll be back periodically over the next four years. I'll get a Guiness next time...
Mr. Fogarty and his staff helped host a surpise party for my Sister and 28 of her family and friends. They couldn't have done a better job! I highly recommend if your are looking for a place to host a party -- look no further, JC Fogarty's is the place.
Food, service and choices of beer were good, did not need to wait to be served,,an relax atmosphere, great place to hangout with friends and watch football.
Large venue spot in village of Bronxville
Friendly,efficient service in a private party room for 50+ persons, buffet style individuals take their own plate, fall in line and served by 2 staff, ample portions of Hearty green salad, Salmon in white sauce, chicken cutlets, eggplant parmigiano, penne pasta in tomato sauce, carafes of red and white wine set on each table of 10, availlable street parking.
Out of curiosity, can someone tell me, does this bar have right-wing vibes? The flags make me think so. Food was good, atmosphere fine otherwise, but I really can’t do right-wing and I just want to know. I don’t think the Republican thing even reflects Bronxville since, like, the Reagan years, and we’ve al grown since then, thankfully. Fingers crossed I’m wrong. Please let me know.
I came in here for lunch after about five years since my last visit. (I moved out of town for a bit). I sat at the bar and was reminded why I used to come here all the time.
The bartender, Jimmy, was friendly and helpful with recommending a sandwich. I had a dietary requirements for my meal and that was not an issue at all.
I got the chicken club (sans bacon) and it was delicious. The chicken was really tender. I'm used to chicken on a sandwich being dry, so you can tell the chicken was cooked to order.
The french fries were amazing. Usually I only eat a few, but I cleaned my plate.
I will definitely keep coming back to Fogarty's, especially at lunch time with the fantastic staff there.
We liked Fogarty's. They have a great selection of well prepared fish and seafood. A good variety of beer and wine.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Bronxville
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes