Anthony's Coal Fire Pizza

This was our first time back since the Pandemics. We ordered pizza and wings to go so I could spend sometime with my husband. We live less than 10 minutes away from the restaurant, and it took about an hour to pick up our food. My husband waited a little bit after getting. Then the server accidentally charged us two times without informing my husband. My bank sent me an alert stating 2 transactions at the same location. That's when the server stated she is new and she accidentally charged us for someone else's food. My husband waited to speak to a manager and to confirm the transaction is voided. By the time he got home with the food, they were cold. Neither the pizza nor the wings tasted good. I called the second day and spoke to manager Tony. He was super nice and willing to help. He stated he would double check to confirm we are not being charged two times and also he would give us credit for food as our food got cold last time. We finally made it in to order the food again. This time, we ordered pizza and long hot meatball mozzarella. Let me tell you, both were delicious. My husband stated the food was delivered in a timely manner as well. Would highly recommend this place if you have not been there.

I paid $46 for burned wings and a small thin crust pizza. Nowhere in the menu did I see it was thin crust. Nothing was unique about the pizza. It had a very dull salsa and cheese flavor like any other basic pizza and the crust was too thin for us to even taste it. The wings were incredibly burned and had no seasoning or sauce to it. I'm actually very angry I paid for that food. Me and my wife were VERY disappointed in the food and just threw most of it away. Also they only offer ONE refill. Over priced place with low quality food. I'm never going back to any Anthony Coal fired pizza.

I was very excited to try this pizza, since I love New York style pizza. The cheese and sauce very tasty, but the pizza was burnt on the bottom and very hard. We also got garlic knots but they where black on the bottom and very tough to bite. These too would have been delicious because they had lots of garlic and parmesan on them but it was hard to get past the burnt bitter taste. I'm not sure if I will try it again or not but had potential to be great pizza.

Do not get delivery. Not their fault but I had an order due at a certain time and it’s still not here. Called and the kid said “it just came out”. So already I know my pizza is gonna be soggy and my salad warm. 30 min later it shows up. Guess what?..:.it cold. Unacceptable. Try to shop at local places but sometimes you have to cut bait with some.

Food was fantastic. Pizza was the best that I've had in a long time, salad was very fresh and had a lot of stuff I like in it and the meatballs were exceptional, the best I have had, probably ever. We had the daily special, pizza, salad and 4 meatballs. Haley was our server and she was very good. Overall I would consider this the best pizza place to go.