Ny Cupcakery

Have them make you a custom cake. I’ve ordered numerous with different designs. They integrated photos and personalized themes. The cakes are beautiful and very very delicious. Recently my college roommate from Maryland loved her cake that I traveled with so much that it became breakfast the next day.

Custom ordered desserts for a recent event. They did AMAZING! The theme was blue pumpkin and it was spot on. Most importantly everything was soooooo delicious. Honestly so yummy. Lucky to have them in my neighborhood for something like this or whatever smaller occasion too. Would definitely use them again and highly recommend. Thank you!! Edited: I did use them again! For my child’s luau themed birthday party. Custom adorable pineapple cake pops, hibiscus cookies (wow) and assorted mini cupcakes. Can’t explain how good these treats are! The cookies were especially delicious.

THE most incredible humans work at this adorable shop which makes the most amazing goodies. They restored my faith in humanity just a bit when they went out of their way to help me in an emergency after an UberEats delivery disaster. Not only do they truly make the most delicious desserts (there is nothing here that isn’t amazing) but Elisa (or maybe Alyssa) was so helpful and compassionate and I will be singing their praises to everyone I know. This little cupcakery is big on heart, the most incredible designs, and flavor.

There is one main reason why I am rating NY Cupcakery 5 stars.. the service. Sure the cupcakes taste good. Sure they look like cupcakes but the service is what really sets them apart. I am absolutely going to be a returning customer and recommend this place to friends. I called the morning of my gender reveal to order cupcakes in pink and blue frosting. I was immediately told that they can do what I wanted and needed in a short time frame. My husband later went to go pick up the cupcakes and when he returned I noticed that some of the cupcakes were the wrong flavor. I called and asked what we can do. The gentlemen I spoke with personally delivered the corrected cupcakes right in time for my party while having a smile on his face. I am grateful for him and for his understanding of how important this day was for me. He understood I was a stressed mom with another baby on the way and he made sure I was happy and got exactly what I expected. Thank YOU (I am sorry I never actually got his name). I appreciate you! I appreciate what you did for us! I will definitely be returning with 1 hungry toddler and 1 hungry mama to be (again)

Great experience! I've been going there for years and decided to entrust a very important Birthday to them... I was not disappointed! The owner went above and beyond to be extra accommodating. He put together some very unique flavors that combined Birthday with our St Patrick's Day theme. All of our guest were so impressed and raved about the cupcakes! It's truly a labor of love for him and just reinforces why we should all support local businesses. Thank you so much.... I highly recommend this local bakery!