My wife and I recently dined here and had a very pleasant experience. Atmosphere was calm and welcoming. Host was prompt and very helpful. Our server was Martha. She was very personable and knowledgeable about all the dishes and local tourist locations. The food amazing. The Mushroom Crostini was on point. The cheese wasn’t to over powering, and the portion was spot on. I got the Fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken, excellent choice. The alfredo was fresh and creamy and chicken was charbroiled to perfection. My wife had the prosciutto wrapped chicken with marcella sauce. It was what the doctored ordered. All and all, we rate it a 4/5. I do highly recommend if you are looking for good Italian while visiting.
Thanks Mama, we’ll be back.
Nice Italian place near city center. Service was amazing and attentive. Food was on a smaller portion but it tasted great. Loved the clam chowder. Sea food was so fresh you could swear they just jump out of the sea into your plate.
We were looking for some good Italian food after having eaten a LOT of Lobster and Clam Chowder over the past few days, and were lucky enough to find Mama Dimatteo’s!
We had a very good dinner there! We were so happy to find this place!
My wife had the Fettuccine Alfredo and thought it was pretty good.
I had the Eggplant Parmesan and it was delicious! It was quite possibly the best I’ve had! We also enjoyed some Baked Cheese as an appetizer and loved it!
Our server, Alex, was very friendly, helpful, gracious, and attentive!
Parking in Bar Harbor is challenging this time of year, but we found an on street spot about 2 blocks away. No biggie…
They have indoor and outdoor seating available. We had made reservations and our table was ready when we arrived.
I would recommend this place highly and will return myself again when I can!
Mama Dimatteos was a really quaint, cozy Italian restaurant we discovered by reading reviews. We had to get reservations - it is a popular place to eat. The staff were excellent, food delicious, wine list limited but sufficient, and cocktail menu had a variety of delicious drinks. Everything we had was excellent but I really remembered the garlic nuggets which were awesome as an appetizer
We ate there twice during our stay in Bar Harbor and would definitely dine here again. I would definitely recommend this restaurant if you like good Italian food.
Great outdoor seating surrounded by sunflower, grape, tomato, filled planters. Our waitress, Martha, was very attentive and knowledgeable. We had chicken alfredo, meatballs, salad and bread, blueberry soda, and carrot cake. Everything was prepared and presented well.
When you need a break from fried seafood, give this place a try. I had the browned gnocchi and my wife the gorgonzola steak. Both were excellent.
We stopped by for a small meal before turning in for the night; after a full day we didn't want anything heavy so did a few appetizers to share. We sat on the patio which was lovely and had beef kabobs, garlic knots, and mac n' cheese. Everything was super tasty, and the server was amazing. I was having one of those moments where you read one thing, but your brain interprets it as something else... she clarified, then clarified again; ensuring I got what I wanted vs. what I was asking for. Really really appreciated it!
It was a nice end to a great day, and I'd like to go back and try some of their entrees.
Decided to give it a try despite some lackluster reviews, and sadly the food and the experience was average at best.
Easily the best restaurant we went to in Bar Harbor. We wanted to get something different after getting tired of lobster and being disappointed by some other restaurants in this area.
I kept it simple with the Spaghetti Marinara with Meatballs and while the spaghetti itself was exactly what you would expect, their meatballs just took it to another level. They were packed with flavor and I just wish they had given me more than two!
My wife got the Pan Browned Gnocchi and after trying some of hers I regretted not having ordered that for myself. It was absolutely amazing.. I don't know how they made that but wow.. Everything was cooked perfectly and it may be the best italian meal I've ever tasted.
We were also pleasantly surprised to find that they gave us some veggies on the side in the form of brussel sprouts. We're not sure how they were cooked but they tasted great and we just scarfed it down.
If we're ever back in Bar Harbor we'd definitely come here again.
Don't let the funky facade and decor fool you. This is the best Italian food for the money in Bar Harbor. Clam and linguine, as well as swordfish piccata, are fantastic. Also try Gorgonzola salad and a blueberry crisp dessert. Our waiter, Scott, was attentive and helpful with suggestions. Plenty of wine choices and specialty cocktails. I cannot recommend this place highly enough. Make reservations if you want to eat outside.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Bar Harbor
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes