The Fish Trap

682 Sunrise Hwy, 11510-3145 - Baldwin
Recommended by Sluurpy: 2021
🏆 #40 of 42 restaurants in Baldwin
Updated on
Known for: fish
★★★★★ ★★★★★
3.8/5
869 recommendations

Sluurpy Quality Index

PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
55/100
Data Completeness
61/100

Verified Dish

Add Missing Dish

3.8/5
Sluurpometro: 75/100
Sluurpy Score
869 total reviews
TA Trip
3.0/5
4 reviews
G Google
3.9/5
356 reviews
G Grubhub
4.0/5
352 reviews
G Groupon
4.3/5
52 reviews
R Restaurantji
3.6/5
105 reviews

Rating distribution

5★
1
4★
0
3★
1
2★
1
1★
1

Contact Information

📞 Phone: +1 516-771-0002
📍 Address: 682 Sunrise Hwy, Baldwin

🕐 Opening Hours

Open now Closes at 11:00 PM
Monday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Thursday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

Google Reviews

3.9/5
★★★★★
356 Google reviews
C

Cassandra Phillips, REALTOR

2 weeks ago
★★★★★ 5/5
When you’re traveling and have a taste for some good Catfish and get a recommendation… you try it! The Fish Trap came highly recommended This was a 5 star experience from the moment we walked in. Angie greeted us with a friendly accommodating spirit. I love the fact that the menu was simple and the prices were on point. We ordered food to go, was told it would be about 20 minutes. The wait was less than 20. We headed out and enjoyed the large portion of catfish which was cooked to perfection as was the entire order. Located in Baldwin, the location was perfect! The food, seasonings, service, atmosphere and location were amazing!! Next time I’ll try the Shrimp and Grits which I hear are the truth🤩
Read more
Google
C

Christina Williams

a week ago
★☆☆☆☆ 1/5
What a horrible horrible experience / 2 whiting candies Yams and potato salad. Price $14.64 no problem I wanted something different got home excited open the container my whiting looked like two chicken tenders. $14 dollars 💵 what did I pay for I seriously don't mind paying for good food but not for chicken tenders.
Read more
Google
K

Kiana Monroe

4 months ago
★★★★★ 5/5
I ordered jerk shrimp with the lobster Mac & cheese (keep in mind, lobster & macaroni are my least fav foods) and it was very good. Especially the jerk shrimp. The customer service there is amazing. The cashier, Winter, is a very friendly, well-mannered pretty young lady. Will be back soon!
Google
S

ShaQueena Spruill

a month ago
★★★★★ 5/5
The food is really good. Never had problems with any of my orders and this is one of the best fish places I’ve been too.
Google
S

Starskyblue B

3 months ago
★★★☆☆ 3/5
The place was nice and the staff was nice but the food didn’t have any taste. I had the whiting dinner with fries and potato salad. I could only taste the hot sauce.
Google
M

Michael DiSalvo (Mike D)

3 years ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
Went for takeout. Needed something healthy, flavorful and filling. This place hit them all. I ordered the Red Snapper dinner, which came with a dipping sauce and two signature sides. First of all, fillet was big, Definitely filling. Cooked to perfection, pan seared in butter and seasoned right. Topped with a small amount of sliced sweet peppers and onions, just small enough not to overpower the dish. The spinach was drenched in a garlic butter soup. I could have swam in it and drank my way out of it. Sauted asparagus, tasted with the same garlic butter sauce. Both greens were cooked well, not wilted. I will be visiting again. I suggest people reading this to do the same!
Read more
Google
B

Berni Hargrove

2 years ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
The food was great. Well cooked, seasoned, and nicely hot. I had the seafood fettuccine and my wife had the banger shrimp with two sides. The shrimp and salmon in the fettuccine were delish and had plenty flavor. Very filling and delicious with every bite. I think the sauce could've been thicker and a bit less oily but overall I would definitely get it again. Made a shrimp trade with the wife, and the banger shrimp was perfectly fried with a generous drizzle of that delicious sauce you'd expect. Just to be clear, all those shrimp weren't just jumbo in name like some places either. They were big as you'd buy to cook at home 🍤👨🏾‍🍳. For the sides we had the Trap Mac n cheese. Aptly called the Trap Mac for short, and it had lobster in it. Some of the best mac n cheese I've had. It tasted like it was home cooked by someone who knew their way around the kitchen. Other side was the red potato salad and it was ok to good. Some might really like it but compared to the other food, it definitely had less flavor (no relish or onions mixed in). Personally I took it home and added a bit of chipotle Mayo and it put it where it needed to be. Now the only real downside was that you don't get much of a warm welcome from the front service. I guess the expectation is everyone is getting takeout so not much of a need but it does make a difference. Overall all I'd recommend getting food here, but order ahead of time. The dinner menu is sit-down restaurant quality, but don't expect sit-down service (too small anyway). Eat a few bites there maybe, while it's really hot, but you'll get the most enjoyment eating it at home. The lunch menu is more to the level of the name suggests and is probably what I'd recommend if you were going a bit more regularly.
Read more
Google
S

Spliffington TheThird

3 years ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
Great food. Great location. Usually a wait for food but it's worth it for the portion size and taste. So far I've had the Cajun seafood dish and the bang bang shrimp, I'll be back for the king crab and lobster tails.
Google

Explore more in Baldwin

Help improve this page:
← Back to all restaurants in Baldwin

🍽️ Suggest a dish

⚠️ Report error

🚫 Report closed

Do you confirm that The Fish Trap has permanently closed?