I was always drunk when I ate here. But I think it was good...
Good carnitas. Not bad for a tourist area.
What a nice attentive staff. Pretty, authentic, tasteful Mexican motif. The food was delicious. Great place to stop in Avalon!
Fine experience at Mi Casita. Overall it's an average American Mexican restaurant with the typical fair- don't expect anything fancy. I suspect most people come for the giant margaritas.
Food: The portions are gigantic. You can easily split one dish between 2 or 3 people. I recommend the nachos, which were the best dish we ordered due to the copious amounts of cheese on top (which was actually melted all the way, I was quite impressed). The fajitas are quite salty and the burritos are average. The guacamole is alright.
Atmosphere is average: the interior is dated and not well maintained (rips in the seat cushions, etc), the glasses are plastic, the cutlery and napkins are quite cheap. The service however is very attentive and extremely helpful! Our waiter came around often and the order came out correctly and quite fast. Kudos to the service staff, they do their job well.
The food is delicious and staff is really friendly. The Mexican food is authentic and the drinks are perfect. You can get breakfast before noon. We all had something different.
We had dinner here on Christmas Day. We ordered their Christmas special which was some prime rib with mash potatoes and veggies, as well as a salad, and second meal was a carnitas quesadilla . For drinks we ordered beer and their own version of Coronarita called Baja Margarita. The food was delicious, the service was great and quick, the drink was good too. They were very busy and even if they closed at 6 o’clock , they still accepted patrons right after that. We have not gotten any tortilla chips like other tables did, not sure how that criteria works, but we were fine without and left with full bellies. Great recommendation if you wanna try some Mexican food while on the island.
Love this place. This was our second time coming and the first time we left our phone there. They were so sweet to have it mailed back to us. Great food and great service!
Food is good. Service is okay. Asked for a refill on the chips and salsa (those are pretty good) and they charged us $1 for it lol. The beef burrito has very few meat and it’s mostly veggies. Not many vegan/vegetarian options. I ended up just having a side of guac and refried beans. In therms of the drinks, they’re bomb! Awesome margaritas!!
First time coming here and it was okay. The enchiladas I ordered were delicious and the music was great. The service although was pretty slow. They brought our guacamole appetizer AFTER our meal because they forgot about it. The guacamole appetizer is a bit expensive for the serving size. I would say in general the serving portions are too small for their price. But honestly the place is comfortable and they have great music!
Yummy Mexican food. Decor is nice and the staff is helpful. Pretty pricey for Mexican food, however everything on the island is a bit pricier.
I would give it a shot if you are craving Mexican food.
Thoroughly enjoyed the ambiance of this place. Had a great booth by the open windows! Tried the ridiculously expensive margarita flight (in my defense, the price wasn't listed on the menu), and I'm so glad I did! The Cucumber margarita was 🔥🔥, the traditional lime was one of the best I've ever had.
My husband and I both had the tacos combo with Carne asada and it was divine - just like tacos you'd get on the street in Mexico. Highly recommend this place.
Honey Badger (Schmitz)
+4
Friendly service. Tasty meals and good portions. Group of six received our meals at the same time. I recommend and will return another time I'm in Catalina.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Avalon
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes