Mama Sid's Pizza
2240 Barnett Shoals Rd, 30605 - Athens
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#80 of 316 restaurants in Athens
Updated on
Pizza
Italian
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
57/100
Data Completeness
61/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 706-549-6100
🌐 Website:
http://www.mamasidspizza.net
📍
Address:
2240 Barnett Shoals Rd, Athens
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
295
Google reviews
Amazing pizza honestly. Really cheap pizza buffet at like $7. From (I think) 11am-2pm, dinner starts at 5 but no idea what time it ends. They'll make you any pizza you ask for then putting it on the bar. The staff is super friendly too. I'm sad there's not one in CA because it's my new favorite pizza place!!!
Read more
Google
I have been a fan of Mama Sid's since 2006. The service and food are consistently excellent. We always dine in, except for two days ago when I ordered a pizza to pick up. Pictured here are slices of a delicious double cheese pizza.
Google
I had a sandwich from Mama Sid’s. The Italian Super. It was a pretty good sandwich. It was an amazing, it wasn’t unforgettable, But it was pretty good. I would probably go back again but I would definitely do take out. The restaurant overall was kind of dark and dingy and doesn’t look like it’s been updated in the last 10 or 15 years. I would 100% support this play simply because it’s a family owned business. When I was there the place was absolutely packed. That must say something about the place. I’ll go back and maybe try another sandwich and see if it doesn’t knock my socks off!!
Read more
Google
Got there at 8:25 thinking they closed at 9:30. Ordered the buffet. 4 old slightly burned slices and a tiny pile of something I assume had been a dessert pizza were all that was left. My server, nice kid, asked if I had any request. I asked for Buffalo chicken. They brought that out at 9 which is when I realized they were closing. As there were 5 other people there I took 3 slices and sat down. The other server than gave a leaving table a box which is where the other 3/4 of a pie went. Not wanting to keep them there past closing I paid for my "buffet" and left... for some reason paying $3 more than the people who walked out with the rest of the pizza I requested.
Read more
Google
THIS!!! IS HOW PIZZA IS DONE!! Checked them out today for the first time after looking for a good pizza for the last almost 2 years.... Everyone working today was awesome! Chill environment and just outstanding food!! Well done guys see you again soon!!
Google
Great pizza. Not like the frozen guys concoction. Wonderful old timey feels inside. Staff is super friendly and really great.
Google
Best za I've ever had in Athens. I always get Mama Sid's Special cause it is DIVINE. People there are so friendly too!
Google
Just as good as it was 20 years ago! From the classics like cheese and pepperoni, to the exotic pizzas like White Feta with Spinach and Tomattos, and the Smores, Apple, and Honey desert pizzas we just love their pizza buffet. I especially like the crispy sourdough like crust. One of my overall favorite pizza stops in all of northeast Georgia. It is also not uncommon to visit with the owners during the week. The kids also marvel at the magic tricks that happen on occasion. If you have never tried them out you will be pleasantly surprised.
Read more
Google
Explore more in Athens
By cuisine
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: