Hilltop Grille
2310 W Broad St, 30606-3418 - Athens
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#45 of 316 restaurants in Athens
Updated on
Bar
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
56/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 706-353-7667
🌐 Website:
http://www.hilltopgrille.com/
📍
Address:
2310 W Broad St, Athens
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
885
Google reviews
Good food and service. Cloth napkins (woo hoo) and lots of table options. Restaurant is definitely family oriented verses a young hangout. Great selection of seating option from high backed booths to high tops in the bar. Very good staff. Lunches specials were $10-15. My meatloaf and collards was excellent along with my wife’s shrimp wrap and some great fries. Parking could be challenging.
Read more
Google
Went here for a family dinner. It was quite busy so recommend a reservation for a weekend night. We sat in the back area and they had a lovely fire.
Started with chicken tenders and fried green tomatoes. They were very tasty and good for sharing.
I had the ribeye steak with a baked potato. Well seasoned. Cooked to correct temperature. Good marbling. Baked potato came with sour cream...I would have liked some bacon, cheese and/or chives but it was still good.
Finished with the creme brulee and chocolate brownie. Both were good flavor and nice portions.
Read more
Google
Came in on 02-05-2022 about 1530 hours.
The bartender was extremely busy But she was pulling it off.
She left at 4 PM and a new bartender took over.
Between 4 PM and until Danielle showed up, that that bartender was absolutely useless.
We all have "off days".
I get it, but,
Good looks only get you so far.
I felt like a afterthought.
Then Danielle showed up with her groovy green hair.
Danielle walked in and and serviced every customer at the bar that needed it and introduced herself to non familiar faces like myself.
Danielle should be wearing a Cape!.
If I was still in the restaurant business she would be working for me today.
I usually Tip very generously. 30% +
Between 4 PM and Danielle's appearance, I was really having my doubts.
When I cashed out I made a point to do it with Danielle.
I think she was happy.
As far as the food;
I started out with the crawfish gumbo.
EXCELLENT!. 5☆
Then I had the crab cake appetizer. 3 1/2☆
Then I had the salmon entree with rice pilaf and green beans. 4☆
Very well written menu with very nice options.
The wine menu was definitely 5 ☆
As far as the atmosphere, done very well..
Very clean and uncomfortable environment.
Definitely look forward to coming back next time I'm in town.
Peace 😁✌
Read more
Google
Came in for lunch on a Saturday. It was pretty busy. Sat at the bar. Ordered a New York strip which came with a salad and baked potato. Ordered blue cheese dressing for my salad on the side without me specifically asking it that way. Dressing was watery. Streak cooked correctly. Potato with sour cream fine. Food came fairly quickly with appropriate time for me to eat my salad before the steak arrived. Bartender busy but extremely efficient.
Read more
Google
I always enjoy dining here. It is a fairly consistent dining experience. Like with many places, too much food for me. I had the crab cakes this last time; the taste was good but they were definitely soggy, like limp cakes. Maybe they were too large. I'm not sure. My friend had a burger. Since he didn't talk once he started eating, it must have been good. I love the patio, always have.
Read more
Google
Hilltop is a real treat.
The staff is friendly and the food is delicious. I have not tried anything I didn’t enjoy.
Last time we went, a guy dropped the tray with our dinner, and it was apparent that he was embarrassed and frustrated, however he did a great job of keeping his cool and getting everything taken care of. They were apologetic and we were not upset. Accidents happen!
The manager that night was helping to wait tables. She seemed fairly sharp but also a little scattered. It seemed that she did not have great communication going with the kitchen staff, as they were back and forth with my family member of whether or not they had a certain dish in stock.
Other than that, everything was great and all other visits have been phenomenal!
Read more
Google
So delicious! The seafood pasta was amazing and so much food, I could not eat it all. Of course, I did get a brownie and brought it back with me. Yummy!
Google
This place was great. Creative dishes and so very tasty. The downsides were that almost half the seafood menu was unavailable and they forgot to bring our appetizers before the entree. They were nice enough to comp the appetizers but taking home something fried and reheating is never the same thing.
Google
Explore more in Athens
Help improve this page: