Stew Reviews (Stewgee)
+4
Really enjoyed our visit to the Arcata branch.
We ordered far too much pizza - very large portions here - a 14 inch pizza each plus a large salad was more than double what we wanted - a (generous) individual slice and side salad would have been great, or a pizza and a large salad for three.
Anyway, great bases and tasty toppings and friendly service make this a great place for dinner - just don't go mad when making your order.
Best deal in town for pizza slices! If you are seeking a huge New York style slice, Paul's sells a slice of cheese or pepperoni as big as your head for no more than 5.50!
Paul's is the best deal in town for slices both for taste and quantity. Two slices of Paul's pizza is like half a huge pizza.
The service is also amazing, truly great people 😸!
Their chicken fingers with ranch or calamari with marinara are also great. I highly recommend the Chicken Parmesan if you want a full dinner.
Gluten free girlies rejoice. It’s the same 10” $20 gluten free dairy free crust that a lot of pizza places have, and it’s good. Thanks Paul
Amazing pizza, delicious, large and a great variety of toppings 10/10. Fast, prompt service, clean tables and chairs, and basketball games on the TVs.
Easily some of the best pizza I've had in a long time
Awesome pizza parlor with great New York style pizza selection. Huge slices of huge pizzas, they have a nice variety of topping combinations. Two slices was plenty filling for one. Overall a solid A grade.
Service is always good , clean , respectful unless very busy its also pretty quick! Yesterday instead of pizza I tried the lasagna 😋 it was better than expected i was very pleased
You can't beat this place! The price and what you get is perfect. A very large slice of pizza is what I had, the thin crust was browned perfectly with a nice crunch. Toppings were fresh and hot. I will be returning.
The takeout baked ziti must have weighed at least 4 pounds and it healed my trauma 🧡 thank u
Food is good. Lunch special offers good value in particular. Service is noticeably more friendly than the Eureka store.
This is the pizza I grew up with and my personal gold standard for pizza. Great sides too- I can recommend their garlic knots and their Thai peanut chicken wings.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Arcata
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes