Mark Fallon
Tastes like a NY slice. They got the crust flavor down, which is very rare. Passes the fold, hold and walk down the street crust. Flavor all there. $4 for a pepperoni slice. Ordered at street window. Tables outside/sidewalk to sit and eat.
Chris Diggs
Biggest, best slices in Wilmington. And possibly the largest variety of flavor combinations of any of the pizza places in the area. A definite must try when you're in the area. And they are open late on Friday and Saturday night.
Matt Curran
It's NY Pizza served by the slice, from a service window, at 2am. Yes Please!! It's amazing thin crust deliciously topped, crispy pizza. Perfect as a quick snack during the day or night.
Plus, the conversations you'll hear standing in line are amazing!!
Be ready to order. Order by the slice instead of asking them to make you a personal pie (it takes longer the personal pizza way), and be ready to be amazed. It's literally the perfect way to end a night out.
CAROL DAVIS
Food was delicious & customer service outstanding! Our pizza slices were heated to perfection & one of the gentlemen came from behind the counter to wipe down a booth for us to sit & eat. It was a very pleasant experience for a last minute dinner in downtown Wilmington. Hours later & still FULL!
Kim Pacheco
They are ALWAYS OPEN late which make a difference leaving the late night Wilmington scenes. The team is kind…lines are long and you tend to wait on the sidewalk but it’s better than nothing.
The pizza is not consistent; you won’t ever know what you’re getting unless it’s the basic cheese, sausage or pepperoni.
Julia Mancari
Best pizza you can find. Great service. They know my husband by order/voice. Always hook our order up. Cheated once and tried slice of life cuz of a card issue/order online. NEVER AGAIN WILL I LEAVE MY FAV PIZZA PLACE. I love NY has my heart forever. Extra cheese, extra sauce, pepperoni 4evr
Aaron McRoy
I go a few times a month while downtown. Food is always good. Keep up the good work guys.
Natalie McAdams
Delicious and authentic NY style pizza. They have slices and whole pies.
(Not sure if it was the norm or like this everyday but it was Take out service only which was a hot day with limited outdoor seating).
Raul Rojas
Very good pizza. I'd put this on my top 5 NY pizzerias outside of NYC. Their pizza sauce reminded me of one of the pizzerias from back home in Brooklyn. Pizza was fluffy and well put together. Cheese and sauce was spot on! They even have square slices. Recommended for any NYer who finds themselves here.
Tatiana Gibson
Waited 45 minutes in line to get pizza and it was worth it. The pizza was very good and hot. They do accept cards. My pizza was as big as a my head and was $4.82 with taxes
Russell Wynne
Great little pizza shop for on the go. They do not have indoor dining, but three small tables on the sidewalk. Overall the service and food were good and they treated our party of 12 very nicely.
D. Heather Campbell
Best pizza in Wilmington! The location on Front Street has been around forever and still consistently makes the best pizza and has so many options! Been my favorite since I discovered them in the 90s!!
The BBQ chicken, white pizza and Rio rancho are some of the locals' favorites. I personally love the super thick crust Sicilian, but you just can't go wrong with any slice here! True New York fold-in-half deliciousness!
Megan C
Great service and everyone loved the pizza I brought to the bar we were all at.
Elle T
They only offer take out but the slices were big and it had ample toppings.
Shawna Renee
This is the most amazing flavor in a pizza I have experienced here in Wilmington NC !!! I will continue to support I Love N.Y. Pizza . And the Staff is so friendly and Lovely !!! Excellent overall experience!!! Must try !!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes