Review Positano Brickoven Pizza - Williston Park

Omg!! I can say that this has the best Italian food I have ever had!! Authentic Italian at its best!!! Staff and service was outstanding!!! Wish I can give it more than 5 stars!!!

Positano Ristorante & Pizzeria tucked away in Williston Park has been there since 1996. What a gem. Upon entrance you think you are walking into your neighborhood pizzeria. Then you look straight back and you are transformed into Positano Italy. Upon being seated you are offered a beverage and  a basket full of homemade focaccia and rolls. The menu is extensive with so many choices of fresh Italian dishes. The appetizers are amazing. they are all cooked fresh to order. I ordered and had a fruity cosmopolitan made special for me. It was just delicious and refreshing.The calamari came out fresh hot and tender. Served with a spicy marinara sauce, this hands down was the finest calamari I have had. in a very long time. It was so tender that you knew it was freshly made. The mozzarella sticks had such a cheese pull that we laughed at how long it was. The potato croquettes were pillowy light and fluffy. The rice balls were tender and flavorful.The tricolor salad was a showstopper with arugula, tomato, red onion, cucumber, orange segments and mozzarella balls, tossed in a fantastic balsamic dressing was amazing. The choices of pasta dishes were many. I had the Fettuccine Carbonara in a creme sauce, loaded with onion bacon. It was luscious. the Farfalle Boscaiolla with chicken, peas, mushrooms and onions in a creamy pink sauce was just divine. The Chicken Sorrentino was layered with eggplant, prosciutto and mozzarella in a light wine sauce was fabulous. The Chicken Verde was stuffed with fresh broccoli, prosciutto and cheese was glorious. The showstopper of the meal was the dessert platter. Tire Mi Su, Cannoli, American and Italian Cheesecake was over the top. Flavorful, rich and luxurious, I could go back just for the desserts. Positano Ristorante & Pizzeria is in a shopping center in Williston Park, NY. When you enter, you are introduced to the pizzeria. Then as you look up and see the restaurant, it is just lovely. With beautiful warm tones of brown and beiges, it is charming. You feel as if you were sitting in a villa in Italy. The lighting is is lovely and the music is easy listening. The service was outstanding. Every staff member was friendly and many have been there from opening day.  We were fortunate to meet the owners. They are the loveliest of people. The pride they have in the food that they offer is very apparent. I must say they are so accommodating and accomplished in this industry.  I had the opportunity to learn the background of some of their special dishes. Positano Ristorante & Pizzeria is a fabulous Italian restaurant. The food is fresh and made to order. I always rate an Italian restaurant by its sauce. Their sauce  was definitely delicious.  There is  a full service bar and many different varieties of wine and beer. The pizzeria is fantastic with many different  of toppings. This restaurant is a gem that you must try. You definitely will be so happy that you did.

I am writing to thank you for a fantastic and memorable evening for me and my family at your restaurant. I would love to see you continue offering such an appreciating dining experience to your guests and wish remarkable success to your business. Thank you Carlo

Stopped in on our way back to Delaware. Still as good as we remember from five years ago. A heavy crust that is cooked well. Very filling and delicious. Half meatball ,half eggplant. Awesome.

They have the best seafood salad around. Large portions! The minestrone soup is delicious and a meal by itself

Walking into Positano is like walking into Nonna's home. It's not just a pizza place, but something very special.....you are in Nonna's kitchen. There is a very comfortable feeling when you sit down that you are about to embark on a very special culinary journey! Our hosts Jorge and Nancy couldn't have been nicer! Plus our waiter Carlo was fantastic! He was the perfect personality for our table. He understood exactly what we were looking for and delivered a delicious culinary journey. I don't even know where to begin. The salad was not your typical salad. Plus the addition of Orange brought it to a whole new level. The Squinguili, Calamari,Shrimp, Baked Clams were off the charts! The Veal Parmasean was excellent! As was the pasta with Chicken and Mushrooms! The Baccarat was sweet and balanced. The desserts were absolutely perfect! This will be my go to place for Italian food going forward. I can't wait to go back. UPDATE We have been coming back again over and over since our first experience at this outstanding dining experience. I love The Parkside...however Positano can definitely go punch for punch with that restaurant. We love both and will continue to enjoy both! ❤️ In any event the food tonight was exceptional. The appetizers consisting of baked clams, stuffed mushrooms, stuffed shrimp, stuffed artichokes and eggplant rollintini were very good. The bread basket is tasty as well. Once again the Veal Parmasean dinner was excellent. If you enjoy desserts, ours were off the charts delicious. I have to say that the Canolli and Tiramisu were the best that I ever tasted. They are made on the premises. Both were creamy, well balanced, full of great flavors and came with a wonderful homemade cream. Truly heaven on a plate. The presentation was also terrific! This is a very special place. Once again, the staff was great. Our server Jeanine was wonderful and Carlo was just fantastic as he has been every time we visit! The owner Jorge made his rounds with a continuous smile. He came over to our table several times to ensure that we were satisfied. You can tell the pride and love he has for his restaurant. It is definitely felt by his customers and there was a full house tonight. We left happy and tremendously satisfied. We will be back again sooner than later!

Great food, employees were very attentive. A+ chicken parm and grandma slice. Zeppoles after dinner for the win

I have mixed reviews for this place. I went Saturday with my scorching hot date, and even though we had 7:30 reservations, we were not seated until 8:10. That’s fine it’s busy, I get it. But while reading a menu and standing on line, a “regular customer l” came by and snatched it out of my hands ‘in good fun’ he seemed inebriated though he hadn’t been seated yet either. He was always rude to the wait staff. Unacceptable. The atmosphere was nice, place is a touch too small, but the food was good, only complaint is that my penne and broccoli with garlic and oil was drowning in oil. Bread was good, and that’s major brownie points for me. Would definitely give them another chance, but I be wary!

Came across this place by chance and the food was delicious! Staff was courteous and well humored. Would def recommend this place!

We randomly chose to visit Positano after a day at Herrick’s Festival because we read the great reviews and decided to give them a try. As soon as we walked in, my family and I were greeted like family. They make you feel welcome and their food was delicious and everything is homemade and fresh. From the fried calamari to their tiramisu and everything in between - we enjoyed it all!!! Carlo and team were amazing. We are from Queens but next time we visit New Hyde Park, we will be sure to visit Positano again. Give them a try - you won’t be disappointed!

Delicious food! Huge portions. Probably the best gnocci I've had Super soft pillows of dough. Great chicken parm

The pizza is gooood, the service is fast and the man who took my order was so kind! Because of that I hope their business multiplies!

Came back here after a while and have to say that I need to update the review. I usually get takeout from here, and the regular slices are great, the Sicilians are on point and the buffalo chicken pizza was transcendent. And the service is as warm and friendly as I remember. It has been a while since I have dined in, but I plan on doing that soon enough, and I doubt I will be disappointed.

What a hidden gem! Everything was superb, will definitely be visiting again!

Introduced to this lovely little place by a friend and coworker. Pizza at front end and dining room in the back. Attentive service, cozy ambience, and delectable homemade dishes ~ we especially loved the chicken cacciatore. Fresh pizza bread and piping hot dinner rolls served with your meal. Loved the Zeppolis and strawberries for dessert. Reasonably priced. Ample parking. We will be returning!!!

I have been eating the spaghetti puttanesca for as long as I can remember. It is phenomenal. The absolute best puttanesca I have ever had, consistently! Bravo!

I stop by for some pizza once a week. I've plenty of choices where I could go and I make sure I come here. Their sauce is top shelf. Try the "Grandma" slice and you'll see. I've no idea where the negative comments come from. It's a super friendly spot that treats everyone like family.