I still LOVE this place. This is great south jersey pizza. I have seen reviews that complain about the grease and soggy crust but I will say that to me this screams real Jersey boardwalk pizza. I recommend just plain and add the spices they provide to you on the table. Of course there was not a crumb left when we were done. Service is average so that would be the biggest draw back for me. If you are on the Wildwood boards Mack's is a must stop for a pie.
Still my favorite after all these years! Been going to Macks since I was a kid And even now 40 years later two claims slices and a birch beer still taste the same. Prices are still reasonable for being right on the boardwalk. It's definitely a greasier slice than most but that's the way I like it. Woman at the front counter gives you prompt quick service with a touch of an attitude that anyone would love but there's always a thank you and have a great day at the end!