Sluurpy > Restaurants in West New York > Presto's Pizza

Presto's Pizza - West New York - Photo album

We loved this place that we went twice in a week...! This is a family owned restaurant with good Italian food. I tried the chicken fingers with honey mustard sauce, garlic bread with cheese, fries, penne alla vodka. Liked all of them. However, I wasn't a fan of chicken rigatoni. The owner was sweet

I am so disappointed of this place; I ordered a Medium Margarita Pizza and added Mushrooms. The price, $28.50 for a Medium Pizza 🙄. They took over 1 hour to Deliver the pizza, I still tipped the driver and gave him a pen because he didn’t have a pen and my pizza arrived cold. The flavor…. Well, I k

Came here 3 days straight for lunch! Cute spot, history and great vibes. Let the old man know I said hi since he’s the sweetest. Perhaps this place will hook you up with free dessert as well shhh 🤫

Best margarita pizza ever.. we usually order the medium pizza or the large with hot wings that’s also delicious. The owner treats everyone with a sweet voice and he is very grateful. I recommend it to anyone in the area of West New York or tourists looking to eat a yummy slice !!

My sister bought me chicken noodle soup for 7$ And the soup had no noodles. It would be more appropriate to call it vegetable soup on the menu because that is what it was.

Enjoyed the brick oven pizza with fresh mozzarella and the chicken with eggplant was delicious! The only thing we didn't love was the cheesecake...seemed store bought. Everything else was very good and we will order again.

I woul like to say that this place has the best owner , not only because of the good food and great quality of pizza , his energy is AWESOME !!! Even if you call and you are having a bad day he will change it , because Omg his energy is amazing!! God bless him and his business ! My fam and I we are

I have been coming here for two decades because the pizza is incredible! Truly the best in the area. Nothing comes close.