Mario's Pizzeria - West Milford - Photo album

I order from this place weekly because the food is great. The sauce and crust on the pizzas are perfect. The meatball subs are top notch. The only reason I give 4 stars instead of 5 is because of unrealistic times given on the phone. Add 10 or 15 minutes to whatever they say. It's worth the wait an

Pizza is good but it takes longer and longer to arrive for delivery. We order 2-3 times a month and our average wait is over an hour, sometimes over 90 minutes and we live a mile away. Time to try a new pizzeria.

Great place to enjoy a freshly prepared meal; made just for you and your family! Serving more than just your basic pie! We also offer a variety of other amazing food too! Come on in and dine out! Call in advance and we'll have it ready for pick up; or stay in and enjoy our convient delivery service

Marios is my favorite Pizzeria in town. The staff is always friendly and patient. I am very picky about my pizza and I love their sauce and crust. Those 2 ingredients make a home run in my opinion.

Very disappointing, I used to order from Mario's all the time years ago, so my family decided to give them a try. There is obviously no passion in the cooking. Pasta was over cooked and not cooked in salted water, My chicken Franchise was so salty it was inedible, the chicken it self were chicken ch

Great pizza. Kid friendly and can order online. Perfect! I try to take my kids every Tuesday since they love to go to Mario's! Pizza and cartoons on the TV there what could be better ;-)

Delivery is always quick, the drivers are courteous and the food is excellent. The online ordering system tends to be offline on occasion, but they always pick up the phone quickly to take orders direct.

Very rude staff. Telling customers that the special that is on their website is no longer valid and that their website is down. Here is the screenshot of their website. Save your $ and skip this place, pizza is bland and extra oily..