Sluurpy
Reset

There are 6 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in West Islip

There are 6 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Teresa's Pizza
95/100 (88 ratings)
Restaurants
Campania
Seafood
Pizza
Italian
Northern-Italian
Southern-Italian
Pizza
Neapolitan
Seafood
Campania
Italian
Northern-Italian
Sicilian
Southern-Italian
Sicilian
Neapolitan
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
Seafood
Northern-Italian
Southern-Italian
Neapolitan
Sicilian
Pizza
Campânia
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Monte Di Procida Ristorante & Pizzeria
88/100 (19 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
"Quiet place with good service and consistently good food. Excellent..."
Thomas Price
"Consistently great food! Never..."
Theresa Macri
"Fabulous Family Run Italian Ristorante ! Fresh and Fantastic Food ! Highly..."
Christina H
""
Kevin Flaherty
""
Johnny D
""
Liliana Argueta
Cafe Europa
83/100 (1574 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"It’s really nice to see young people with really friendly attitudes & a great sense of customer service. These are traits that have completely..."
Brian Cosgrove
"So happy Cafe Europa went out of business, the manager was cold and verbally abusive to his staff. It’s nice to know he’s no longer there and we..."
fra (frareviews)
"Always good food, friendly service, and they show that they appreciate your business, which is rare these..."
Jonathan Linder
"Update: Still amazing! Been going here for years and I'm very picky pizza person. Favorite place for pizza! I literally drive almost 10 minutes to..."
Amy Steff
"I love this place I have dined in and had take out for years and it never disappointed. There food has always been always fresh, on point absolutely..."
vincent muscato
"Cafe Europa has delicious pizza, but it’s the warm and friendly service that keeps everyone coming back. Mike, Joe, AJ, and the entire crew do an..."
Marcy S
"Some of the best pizza in the area and reasonably priced. Plus they have turtles in time to play for free while you wait. Really like their version..."
Tom Cyr
"Cafe Europa, simply put, is excellent! Picked up another order last night and the sicilian pizza, cold antipasto salad with shrimp and chicken rolls..."
Anthony B
"Best Grandma and pepperoni pizza I ever had in my life. Me , my wife and daughter have declared it our favorite and only pizza we order . Thanks..."
Mike C
"When moving to West Islip 3 years ago we must have sampled every local pizzeria and were never thrilled with what we had.... that is until we tried..."
Christine Mencarelli
"Cafe Europa makes an awesome Sweet Thai Chili Cicken pizza! If you're looking for something on the healthy side, the Vanessa Skinny pizza is a good..."
Donna Angiulo
"Staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming! We really enjoyed the pizza as well. Asked for the kids slices warm and got them warm, which is a very..."
Johnny Salazar
"I ordered through Grubhub originally the food came fast and it was delicious. I ordered from them again today straight to the restaurant. I’m very..."
Mell
Anthony's Pizza & Pasta
82/100 (896 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Hello all, I am the Owner of Anthony's pizza, I've seen a few of these reviews and I also see replies, none that come from me. As far as boiled..."
Anthony Musumeci
"Lot’s of options to pick from such as slices. Also a lot of options on the menu. Great Prices. Food is always fresh. Owner is very nice and..."
marcella
"Just placed my Christmas catering order at Anthony’s which I do every Christmas. The quality of the food and the service never disappoint. We..."
Janice Veiga
"This is by far my favorite pizzeria. The most delicious sauce, and fresh mozzarella. The crust is cooked perfectly. All of their other food is..."
Lisa Palermo (Assoc Real Estate Broker)
"They have the best pizza. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese.we have not been disappointed yet with their food. Great meals, everything..."
K O
"Quality pizza, delicious garlic knots and a Sunday deal that can't be beat! They lost a star because they don't deliver to apartments and parking..."
kevin abrams
"These reviews are NOT correct. Anthony (the owner) has been nothing but great to me. The first time I went he was nothing but NICE and WELCOMING guy...."
Gary Looman
"This place was amazing I was driving by and my baby had a diaper blow out I pulled over they were kind enough to provide me with gloves gloves..."
Carlos Jimenez
"Amazing pizza! Great slices! The crust isn’t floppy and it has just the right amount of seasonings! Chicken bacon ranch slice is..."
Kyra Wrigley
"First time having pizza from them last week, loved it! A little too expensive for me but the pizza was delicious. Will be a once in a while splurge..."
Lauren Quinn
"Great Pizza and delicious food. Super friendly staff, clean and the owner is an amazing guy!! They do all my..."
Darlene Munoz
"Very kind and nice friendly staff. The pizza is made the way you like it, delish . Will go there..."
Debra g
"Best pizza in west islip. To top it off the pizza delivery guy, Jason Marra was amazing. We love this..."
leigh marra
Oak Neck Pizzeria
79/100 (212 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Ok so I am extremely picky with pizza. I have only gone to one pizza place for the past 6 years. That place was way out of the way today so I stopped..."
F W
"Oak neck pizza is quietly a real gem of a restaurant that I feel gets passed up on for whatever reason. Food is extremely delicious and I highly..."
Brian Huber
"We used them for a 30 person catered party and usually go to them on a normal basis as well! However we and all of my guest were overly impressed..."
Nicole Calderone
"Decent food . Not fancy food. Pizza is.made fresh daily. Very young staff without masks. The heros are not made with fresh chicken and small..."
Robert Voce
"I love this place! I've been going here for years and just stumbled onto it on my way to the dog park. I get their specialty slices and their Grandma..."
Jules R
"Absolutely love this place. Best pizzeria on Long Island in my opinion. Great food and amazing service! The owner Bahji is always there and she is so..."
Chris Buetti
"My family and I love this place! The pizza is really good! The main dinner entrees are delicious! My staff and I also love the friendly faces. Keep..."
Anthony Dixon
"I just want to say I love this place. It's so nice to be so close to a great pizza place. Their food is always excellent and they deliver quick. Our..."
Brandon Billings
"We eat here very frequently and they never disappoint us! We have also ordered catering through them and our whole party was extremely happy with all..."
Nicole Calderone
"My wife and I are both full time and eat out almost every night . We have many different choices and we choose Oakneck pizza . They are very..."
M R
"Very friendly nice people pleasant experience is important when you're having dinner the calzone was the best I ever had no wasted do space all..."
August D'Alessandro
"I have been eating here for years. Love the pizza...."
TECHTOKDOC (CB)
Chuck E. Cheese
73/100 (1699 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Gift Cards Available
Dinner
Lunch
"Great place to take the family. I took my two little nieces to celebrate my bday and the staff was amazing, they were patient with answering my..."
Christina Sutton
"Great place! Very clean, delicious food and drinks, fun place for adults and kids. Lots of games available. While we we there there was a birthday..."
VALERIYA I. New York
"Great place to take your kids. I personally don't like the Pizza, but my child loves it. The arcade games are great and there is something for every..."
Karen Humphrey
"Very nice, I put the menu on here so everyone can see what's new and what's not. I would suggest buying the bulk package of tickets or it could get..."
Harry D
"The young staff that works there really tries to make your time an enjoyable experience. The older gentleman that works at the front can be a bit..."
Christopher LeBron
"Nicely renovated. There's no climbing tube but a lot more games and much cleaner. They have a new time based payment option that gave me 1.5 hours..."
Brian Kupchik
"Twas a great party for.my 8yo. Everyone had lots.of fun. Our host MJ was very professional. Would recommend..."
amecia ollivierre
"We went for a birthday party, and the place was very clean (even the bathroom), well run, everything was working, the party attendant was great and..."
Ashley Lefèvre
"Go early! Best time no crowds! Chuck E gets to interact more with the..."
Cynthia Alexander
"I had my nieces 2nd Birthday Party here. Space was very clean and organized. I appreciated that the games and rides for toddlers were separate from..."
Tempestt Harris-Bucknor
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use