Sluurpy > Restaurants in Wantagh > Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza - Wantagh - Photo album
I saw some negative comments about the pizza being burnt and what not but I gave it a shot anyway and this is the best pizza I’ve tasted so far. Cooked to perfection and tastes, absolutely fresh. I’m sure the guys probably have some off days once in a blue for those complaining about anything.
I like their pizza but I go there for the wings...by far my fave. But even better than the wings is the service. My server, Destiny, is the shining jewel of this restaurant. She is always smiling, very knowledgeable, and goes above and beyond for her patrons. Give this girl a raise, she deserves it.
Great Anthony’s salad, very affordable prices, good service, social distancing and famous chicken wings. For me personally it was a little bit burned. I can’t have little black coal pieces in my mouth. Sorry. But I know for sure some people love it. So, people it’s up to you.
Not only is the pizza amazing but they have a honey margarita that pleasantly surprised me. I can't wait to go to this restaurant again to try more food off the menu.
Amazing food and great service, i bring my 85 year old mom and the daytime help especially is so patient and nice
Stopped at Anthony's after a movie night, and the food was delicious!!
We had the jumbo wings, and meatball pizza, and it was great!
Friendly and attentive staff, great overall experience . Definitely a place worth visiting while in Bellmore, NY.
Go hungry though, the portions are generous!
Yummy 😋
Nice place to go for a drink and a bite by yourself, friends or a couple. Bar - customers are friendly, wait staff and bartenders are friendly. Food's good, happy hour is good. Pizza is NOT burned! That's the " coal fire" way it comes out!! I often come by myself and never feel alone.
This is a great place to enjoy awesome food with family and friends..
. Their service is really top-notch and their staff are obviously well-trained :) I highly recommend this restaurant!
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Thank you very much!
Delicious food and great service. We went on Sunday in the early afternoon and we had the whole restaurant to ourselves. The waitress brought us two garlic knots since it was our first time. We ordered garlic romano wings for appetizer and the Carnivori pizza. The food was amazing.
Prices are very good. Food is also good. They used to have a better beer selection. We eat here frequently.
Not the Best pizza but good on the Wednesday special*
Love the Eggplant
Nice sause *
Oh and garlic knots
You can't miss this place! It's right in your face and angled on the street so it can be easily seen. Access to ample parking is available from both a side street and the main road. Once inside it is quite spacious and table placement offers plenty of room for all. No cramping here.
And now the foo
The pizza was cooked nice and crisp with thin crust the way we like it. Everything was fast and fresh. My only gripe is I think the portion size is a bit small for the price and I’ve come here a few times to only leave right away because the wait was over an hour to sit down. Also the menu is somewh
Good pizza, good salad, the manager went out of her way to try to make us cappuccino, but the machine was broken... very sweet
Good food for a decent price. Pizza and wings are really good. The Italian Tuna Salad is really good. Staff was nice too. They only have cheesecake for dessert which was really the only bad thing.
Great Food!Great Service!I'm Going Back Definitely.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes