This unassuming little place is actually a goldmine! The very best corned beef hash I have ever tasted, made from scratch (ask for it crispy!), great soups, fast and efficient service from real-life sweethearts. If you ever have room, try something from the dessert display, or take it to go! So delicious!
Catherine O'Shea Hamilton
+5
Our family feels you are the best diner on the Island . We are always treated with a smile . The food is exceptional & your establishment is very accommodating to our growing family . We ordered take out gyros & loved them . I ordered a giant size lemon soup & ate the whole thing . Thank you for being so attentive & having delicious food !
A classic Long Island diner. I'm always ordering breakfast, so I can't speak too much on the lunch/dinner entrees, they do have an insane coleslaw I've tried. I've been eating here every week for the past few months, it's scrumptious. Get an omelet, homefries, buttered white toast, and a cup of coffee or tea and live a little!
Love this diner. It's our ritual stop after visiting Calverton Cemetery. Food is great and fresh and the service is top notch. Good bakery items at the counter too!
Fantastic food, especially if you need to eat gluten-free. I love how they serve you out the window still, even though the pandemic is over. Saves you time when you can just park at the curb and run up. I highly recommend their avgolemono soup - delicious! And their Greek salad wraps are massive! Good fries too.
As a Turkish and Aegean (from Izmir) I can say that the best Sarma (stuffed grape leaves) I have eaten in the US. I got a cold. Just minutes ago, I took out a cup of the chicken soup which was also great. The Lady (I think the owner) is so polite and helpful. I am so glad to find a place like my home.
Panini with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and homemade fried eggplant. French fries crispy and delicious. Coleslaw and pickle on side. Portion was great. Took half home. Server Linda was excellent. Would go back again.
I am giving the diner five stars. The first time I went which was December 9 was amazing. December 10, the eggs were awesome and the hash and potatos not so good. The hot Coca was amazing. The Potatos are spicey and the Hash has Potatos in it. Hash is also spicey. I think a survey is needed to see how many people love the Potatos and the hash. You do not like Potatos that are spicey the potatos and hash are not for you. Once you take a bite of the potatos you will notice how spicey it is and it will not be something you will forget. However, if you do like spicey order the Potatos and Hash. The waffles were truly amazing looking forward to the pancakes and french toast on future visits. Overall am pleased with the Greek Island Diner.
They don't take reservations, but they still worked with me to accommodate our large party ahead of time. Such lovely people, and the food was enjoyed by all. It's a step up from a regular diner for sure. Recommended!
We had the specialty salads which were so delicious plus I had the BEST GLUTEN FREE mozzarella sticks I ever ate!! The owner Andy escorted us to our table & explained all my gf options. He also told us about how serous they take celiac disease & they make sure they use separate fryers with no cross contamination. Victor, the waiter, reassured me I would be safe from gluten. Kim the cashier was also very friendly as we purchased a few delicious gluten free cookies for the ride home. We will be back soon even though wading river isn’t close to where we live. It’s worth the hike! 👍♥️
Our yellow hat group has enjoyed several lunches there. Service is excellent as is the food
This might seem like a silly reason to leave a review, but Greek Island makes the absolute BEST well-done onions rings I have ever eaten. We have been ordering delivery from them once a week since COVID lockdown and the quality of food and service has been consistently amazing. The one time my good wasn't up to my expectations, they very quickly made it right. Tonight I had the Reuben with my well-done onion rings and couldn't help but eat the whole dang thing - IT'S THAT GOOD. And I'm always impressed with how well their delivery travels. I can't recommend them highly enough. 😁
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Wading River
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes