Their motto says that they may not make the most pizza but they make the best and that they do. If you are "starving" this isn't the place as they take the time for a truly delicious handmade pizza. Average wait time seems to be 30+ minutes, but it's well worth the "slow service" as it will be one of the best made pizzas you've had. I ordered the pepperoni poppers, a salad, and 12 inch "The Don". All was excellent and cooked to perfection, not overdone or underdone.
I got my fave, Portobello Stuffed Raviola in Alfredo sauce. My husband got his favorite pizza, The Don. Food was delicious as always!
This is the 4th pizza restaurant I've been to in Wabash. It is far above the other 3 I've visited. Delicious cheesy and good bread. Nice job.
Just returned for my second visit. Ordered the chicken, bacon and ranch on a hoagie....amazingly delicious.
Very good. Generous toppings.
A 18” pizza fed my whole family of 5 with plenty to bring home.
Go down and see Alex at goodfellas.. Great pizza and great staff.. Best pizza around.. Lee
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes